that means your getting a chambered and muzzle threaded barrel for $200 so he's probably pocketing about $50-75 an hour.
You misread the post. Labor only, $600 per barrel.
Compared to what I charge ($325 + $100 muzzle thread) it's considerably higher. When threading the muzzle as part of the barrel fitting process (as opposed to someone sending it for threading "standalone") I drop it to $75. I've got to dial in the muzzle anyway just to crown it.
This is why I NEVER...I'll repeat...NEVER take in work without emails documenting scope of work and firm pricing if at all possible.
At the very least, I provide a range of cost with a "cannot exceed" cap. That's just good business far as I'm concerned.
Bottom line is, any smith is entitled to charge whatever they want for their work, this is 'Merica, right?
You've got high-tech large shops, with significant overhead and six figure CNC's they gotta pay for.
At the other end, you've got retired or semi-retired smiths that do excellent work, and are happy with a small clientele.
I've seen sh** work, and beautiful work, turned out by both. At the end of the day, the indicators don't lie.