Starting from scratch - First Lite or Kuiu?

Starting From Scratch - KUIU or First Lite

  • KUIU

    Votes: 79 50.6%
  • FIRST LITE

    Votes: 30 19.2%
  • MIX OF BOTH

    Votes: 28 17.9%
  • OTHER BRAND (LISTED IN COMMENTS)

    Votes: 19 12.2%

  • Total voters
    156
I buy based on how well it suits my needs, that being said for personal reasons and not based on performance, I stay away from KUIU and Sitka. Sitka is anti-O&G - imagine the hypocrisy - their merchandise is made from and with the help of hydrocarbons. KUIU advertises they are not to be associated with big brands because they don't sell to and let their business be run by big retail stores and investors - they are a family business. That's great, but why do you manufacture in China and ask consumers to pay the highest dollar? Their marketing strategy and business model are great, but it also insults my intelligence. That being said I like FL some UA and everything that is wool.
 
...As far as buying American made hunting gear, I would absolutely love to. I've yet to try on anything that fits me and matches my style. Maybe some day, we'll get smart about not outsourcing pollution to our neighbors for cheap labor. It's just too hard for companies to compete. For now, I guess you can call me a disgruntled Kuiu supporter.
My wife and I are now complete fans of Gulch Gear. Both of us have full sets of their camo. It is every bit as well engineered as Kuiu (yes I own pants and a puffy). I'll be purchasing a second set of Gulch for both of us before fall this year.
 
Bought my son Kuiu gear for christmas and got myself a new Kuiu Quik Down coat for myself for casual use. It only weighs a few ounces and is very warm but but I dont think it would make it past lunch time on opening day of hunting season. Only wore it a few times and I have a rip that is molting feathers on the outside and one on the inside. The material is so thin it just wont hold up. Definitely not a $280 coat. Hope my sons gear does better.
 
Bought my son Kuiu gear for christmas and got myself a new Kuiu Quik Down coat for myself for casual use. It only weighs a few ounces and is very warm but but I dont think it would make it past lunch time on opening day of hunting season. Only wore it a few times and I have a rip that is molting feathers on the outside and one on the inside. The material is so thin it just wont hold up. Definitely not a $280 coat. Hope my sons gear does better.
Any ultralight puffy is going to be like this. Despite how frail some of the outer fabrics are on them, I chose weight and compatibility over durability and always carry a roll of tenacious tape with me. Some of my solids have turned camo with all the different color patches. In fact, I have a FL Brooks that needs about 8 more patches on it and a mason jar full of little pieces I caught from it. My lightweight down gear is usually only warn when I'm sitting still, or above treeline. If I plan on crashing through brush, I chose DWR coated fleece.

Climbers, mountaineers and skiers have been patching puffies for years. Spend a minute in any ski town and the Patagucci Posers will be strutting in their bright new jackets with fresh desiccant packs in their pockets while the true powder-hounds, ski patrol dudes, etc., will have a half a roll of duct tape on their coffee and grease stained gear.
 
Any ultralight puffy is going to be like this. Despite how frail some of the outer fabrics are on them, I chose weight and compatibility over durability and always carry a roll of tenacious tape with me. Some of my solids have turned camo with all the different color patches. In fact, I have a FL Brooks that needs about 8 more patches on it and a mason jar full of little pieces I caught from it. My lightweight down gear is usually only warn when I'm sitting still, or above treeline. If I plan on crashing through brush, I chose DWR coated fleece.

Climbers, mountaineers and skiers have been patching puffies for years. Spend a minute in any ski town and the Patagucci Posers will be strutting in their bright new jackets with fresh desiccant packs in their pockets while the true powder-hounds, ski patrol dudes, etc., will have a half a roll of duct tape on their coffee and grease stained gear.
Your write ups are awesome and spot on in my experiences as well. I started with Sitka and went to KUIU because othe fit. I'm 6'4" and a little over 200# and had to size up to 2xl for the ability to layer but still fits me like a XL.
Have the super down jacket and it doesn't have many miles on it but I don't expect it to last long without a few duct tape patches.
Merino vs synthetic base layers. Have both. Usually sleep in the wool (don't like smelling myself) and wear synthetic when active and hiking.

What are your thoughts on the Kenai jacket? I wanted down for the weight but I want something a bit heavier for warmth and not sure I want the Pro down jacket just in case it gets wet.
 
What are your thoughts on the Kenai jacket? I wanted down for the weight but I want something a bit heavier for warmth and not sure I want the Pro down jacket just in case it gets wet.

The Kenai is a phenomenal synthetic jacket and I have a few buddies who swear by theirs. I don't personally own one, but had a Teton jacket until a Wirehaired Griffon named Toby had it for lunch. The Teton was their cheaper line, but very similar to Kenai in insulation material and fabric. It definitely made the list for favorite pieces of hunting gear destroyed by bird dogs. It was warm, super tough, and one of my favorite pieces of gear. Damnit Toby! Not sure what the fabric was, as the specs are hard to find on discontinued gear, but it was surprisingly good at shedding water for the first 2 seasons. I was pretty rough on it which accelerated the wear. I probably wore it for 100+ days hunting and skiing. Near the end of it's life it was probably 75% as effective as brand new, but still awesome-sauce.

The fabric on the Kenai is a 51G with DWR coating. The Super Down is a 9D. The G is for grams/m2 and D is for grams/9,000 m yarn- hard to compare except that 9D is about as ultralight you can get. From hunting with guys that have the Kenai, the material is definitely more durable, windproof and better at shedding water, but by no means going to keep you dry in a downpour. My experience with ALL DWR coatings is that they will inevitably wear and lose their water repellant properties.

In regards to the insulation, 3DeFX+ Toray is all marketing hype for classic Polyfill/Primaloft material. It uses polymer fibers like any other insulation material, the difference is slightly larger size fiber. It is rated about 30% better than "traditional" fibers in a lab according to ASTM standards. Toray never tells us what they are comparing it to. While it MIGHT have better properties, I don't suspect you are going to notice anything revolutionary about it. You'll see similar quality in most higher end synthetics found at REI or similar stores. Essentially, you know it's not cheap knockoff stuff in a typical Cabelas jacket.

The takeaway? DWR jackets with synthetic fill will do well if taken care of. All synthetic insulation loses quality with repeated wear and compression cycles. The microfibers will crack and break down. My hunch is that this is accelerated substantially when cold. Store at room temperature on a thick padded hanger to prevent a crease in the shoulder, minimize folding, avoid folding in the same places, and don't compress too often. I've learned with my synthetic to alternate between 2 folding styles, any more than that, I can't keep track. Don't use it as a pillow, and keep it out of a stuff sack. Backpacking pillows are so light these days and have one of the best ounce to quality of sleep ratio. Don't expect compressibility anywhere near down. Overall, I think it is better suited for day hunts or short 2-3 day overnights when you have room and can afford the weight. If you have bird-dogs, keep blood soaked, gamey smelling clothes in a vault.
 
Update. I ended up going full KUIU, including the pro pack with 2 different bags. I have run the smaller bag with some weight in here on some trails and really like the system. Changing bags is really quick and I got the 7800 bag new from one of our own on here for a great price.

It wasn't cold enough in Europe to really test out the Kuiu layered up but I was melting in the low 40's just standing in my yard.

The attack pant and DCS guide jacket seem very well made. The zip-off merino wool thermals are pretty slick. The down puffy/pants smash down incredibly small. The down pants fit over or under the attack pants and the puffy fits under the DCS jacket with a midlayer on.

I opted for darn tough merino socks vice Kuiu socks. Now to find my some boots. I currently am residing in Italy so Im gonna look at some Crispi's since they are made here.
 
If you are a wealthy person with an endless budget, ignore my response.....

I would suggest not overlooking brands like Arc'teryx, outdoor research, tactical distributors (their in house branded clothing is great for the price), etc. These brands can be found in earth tone colors and perform well.

Clothing is about the material and function, not the camo pattern. I personally like the kuiu attack pants, but there are many options like them (4 way stretch, hip zips). If you need an extremely warm coat, the first lite chamberlain is unbeatable.

I also like sales, full retail is for suckers lol.
 
As Wyo37 mentioned there are other brands that are a bunch cheaper. A couple examples are Marmot Precip raingear. I have a couple pairs of tops/bottoms because they were only $50 each and are almost as good as my Sitka/Kuiu raingear. Another cheaper shirt that wears like iron, dries quickly, and I don't leave home without is Cabela's brand micro-fleece (heavier fabric). I also shop internet sales and usually get deals for around 1/2 price. I hardly ever pay full price.
 
Marmot makes great stuff. I always mix and match brands based on fit and functionality, plus the animals that is shoot don't care that I'm not wearing matching camo.
 
There is only one brand and it's called SITKA don't waste your money on anything else. It's garbage
 
Top