We hunt the Thorofare in Wyoming. I carry either my glock 20 or my ruger alaskan in 454. 200 grain hard cast for the 10mm and 350 grain hard cast for the 454. I use a chest rig so that the pistol is always available even while quartering an animal.
I'm curious which one you shoot "accurately " the quickest !
I've owned a Redhawk 44 mag for about 25 years now. I was charged by a black bear sow when her cub tree'd about 15' from a friend and I . We were packed about 10 miles in the Wenham in Oregon
Archery hunting.( Sidearms were not legal to carry during archery season back then.)
She was a bullet,, she covered 60 yards in about 3 seconds. I couldn't even believe the speed she came in. She looked about the size of a Shepherd on all 4's.
When she threw the anchor out and stood on 2 about 15' from us she went to 6 1/2' tall real quick. We were screwed ! She stopped, squinting to try to make us out ( full camo) wind in our face and froze in place. The cub came down the tree walked about 5' over to her and they both walked off.
I carried (illegally) that 44 mag every year after that.
But I noticed with full house 320 gr Cor bon hard casts that revolver was a handful to accurately shoot when I practiced 3 quick shots.
I've since bought a RIA 10mm Single stack.
Love it, was fast on the 3 shot 220 gr Underwood hard cast. But limited to 8 shots. I guess my point is, with minimal practice (compared to my Redhawk) I'm way faster with the auto.
And last week I bought a XDM 15+1. I'm retiring the 8 round 1911.
Just my 2 cents from someone lucky enough to have this experience and learn from it.