My thoughts on solid copper bullets and in comparison to other bullet types.

Ok going on the twist theme & spinining
Also tumble


Right, a high SG is always desirable. And it's nice that you can get such a high SG with solids compared to some cup and core bullets.

Pic of the one circled in blue is the true tumble as the one that went through the horn in red Apart from a true solid most pills will fail to stay straight if even get to the vitals & I've even seen true solids fail miserably

Back to the one in blue

This pill was extremely accurate & no signs of instability on paper
SF right on the 1.5
Moved to little critters 1 to 5lbs chest width upto 3 inches to se if a pencil would occur
No pencil but on animal preformance while looked impressive the actual time impact to tipping was dismal actually really dismal
Now move to the one that was recovered in blue circle & that was the result with tumbling occurring very quickly in its travel & could be tracked easily
This was replicated again on tumble in next animal so that combo was packed up & moved to the next batch for testing

What we've found by increasing sf to @ least 2 ( more is desirable we believe) the problem is going away

Now you say the petals should be twisted on Barnes if this was the case
Like this you mean
I've seen it heaps & the best one was from a ginger springbok yes a Barnes stopped in a springbok believe it or not & it wasn't a tailpipe shot ( I'll see if I can find it )
SF on this one out of a Rusa deer was just over 3 & my springbok was nearly 5
Yes I accept different resistance but IMO on the shear numbers I've seen this on , it's a pattern that's happening
View attachment 309511View attachment 309512
I'm pretty sure somewhere on this forum Steve, told me they consider it a bullet failure if their bullets don't shed their petals.
 
I was gonna say 3.75 in definitely isn't right😅
It's actually 1.1 mils at 500 yards for that load, so more like 20.3" of drop, just to clarify.
DBBBE2F5-7433-4415-9FB8-6B2F265813C8.jpeg
 
Ok going on the twist theme & spinining
Also tumble


Right, a high SG is always desirable. And it's nice that you can get such a high SG with solids compared to some cup and core bullets.

Pic of the one circled in blue is the true tumble as the one that went through the horn in red Apart from a true solid most pills will fail to stay straight if even get to the vitals & I've even seen true solids fail miserably

Back to the one in blue

This pill was extremely accurate & no signs of instability on paper
SF right on the 1.5
Moved to little critters 1 to 5lbs chest width upto 3 inches to se if a pencil would occur
No pencil but on animal preformance while looked impressive the actual time impact to tipping was dismal actually really dismal
Now move to the one that was recovered in blue circle & that was the result with tumbling occurring very quickly in its travel & could be tracked easily
This was replicated again on tumble in next animal so that combo was packed up & moved to the next batch for testing

What we've found by increasing sf to @ least 2 ( more is desirable we believe) the problem is going away

Now you say the petals should be twisted on Barnes if this was the case
Like this you mean
I've seen it heaps & the best one was from a ginger springbok yes a Barnes stopped in a springbok believe it or not & it wasn't a tailpipe shot ( I'll see if I can find it )
SF on this one out of a Rusa deer was just over 3 & my springbok was nearly 5
Yes I accept different resistance but IMO on the shear numbers I've seen this on , it's a pattern that's happening
View attachment 309511View attachment 309512
That's a good start on proving theory. Your stories also go to show just how unpredictable and uncontrolled things are when actually out hunting.

I did mention that bullets still show evidence of spin as they first center the animal. If they didn't, there wouldn't be plenty of evidence out there that with certain bullets, especially cup and core, higher RPMs allow the bullet to come apart more rapidly than lower RPMs of the same bullet. I've seen this many times first hand. What I see in your example of the lead core bullet is evidence of some influence to the petals of the spin, but not to the degree I was thinking when I mentioned it in my previous comment. Im talking much more aggressive angles to the petals. As long as the bullet expands fully before arresting its spin, you should definitely see angles like that on petals or other pieces hanging off. I just haven't seen anything real aggressive to support that it's still spinning rapidly all the way through until it exits or stops. I suppose though if it's too aggressive the petals will still be ripped off of the rest of the bullet, but you'd think if it were due to spin rate you'd experience that still at lower impact velocities and not just higher impact velocities. This is why impact velocity is more import in general than rate of spin as far as terminal ballistics with most bullets. It's possible having a SG higher than 2.0 helps bullets like the hammer maintain stability as it penetrates through an animal. It could be coincidence too. I like to give the benefit of the doubt though, so I'll say you're on to something.

What I'd really love to see though is a much more controlled testing of this stuff with lots of data and evidence to examine rather than theories based on a few experiences. I wish I had the time and resources myself lol. Sometimes all you have is trial and error. I applaud your efforts thus far.
 
Last edited:
If I may I'm gonna tell you what Fordy has came up with in the Hammer world, "Velocity Brackets" There has been a ton of testing done and this was what fordy came up with for Hammer bullet selection, Take Your maximum intended range, adjust your projectiles weight to find maximum impact velocity for that range ( Providing your twist rate will stabilize your choice) We concentrate on impact velocity with Hammers and disregard energy numbers. Now here is where folks start shaking their heads, Hammers upon impact shed petals ( Stick with me because here is where it gets interesting) we are not sure if the petals are ahead of the shank pulling it or behind the shank in tow but the petals stay with the shank making mush out of everything as they go. Combine that with both of the Hydro's multiplied by the extra speed we are achieving and then add that your shot placement is basically unlimited .............. we have found some very deadly combinations

pPus - Don't forget the much higher twist rate/spin rate on the Hammers. This spin rate issue has yet to be fully explored.
 
Top