WildRose
Well-Known Member
Agree, copper is harder, but... how big would you say the slug would have to be to give it really great penetration, you know the weight and length dimension... we know that the diameter of the 12ga is .729 inches. I wouldn't think you'd want to expand that slug it would just shorten the penetration in a big animal. I believe Federal had a "solid" copper "no expansion" slug at one time, something like 437grs aka 1oz at 1500 fps and it was a flop if I'm not mistaken. I think nearly all, if not all 12ga copper slugs, other than perhaps some specialty one-off versions are HP and/or expansion of some type... I would think if big "solid" copper slugs were worth the weight and material they'd be more popular. I also think the real money would be in a Teflon bronze sabot slug, but... then ATF might have something to say about that., maybe?
Here's one that might work in brass... see the video.
Also in the video, one of the reasons ATF might jump into any type of real production of super hard slugs, so that's just my thoughts on our conversation, enjoy the video. Cheers
The purpose of solids on dangerous game is to ensure the deepest possible penetration.
I don't even know if they are still made but I used Winchester 1 0z rifled slugs with great success on a few really big old boars and sows (pigs) with most getting a complet passthrough punching about a 1" hole most of the way through. They were a hard lead slug.
Many serious DG hunters and PH's prefer hard led, many more prefer some form of copper or brass solid.
Peregrine makes an expanding DG solid copper slug that's really impressive at velocities exceeding 1800FPS up to around 2800. That's the only expanding DG solid I've used on the biggest and nastiest critters.