I'm looking at a 7 mm WSM and it seems to be loosing it's following. I've spoken with several smiths and they've all said that they haven't chambered one for a while. I shoot a 280 AI and and love it. I'm aware the performance of the 7 WSM is only slightly better burning 8-10 gr. more powder but I'm curious what the negative is of the WSM and why guys aren't building them anymore? I'm afraid I may be disappointed if I buy one after I start shooting it.
When your only claim to fame is a short fat case there is not much reason to switch to it if you already have something that does the job. Lack of good marketing and too many new cartridges is the problem. If all that maters is checking boxes on paper than every new and trendy cartridge is a must have. On the other hand if hunting like the title of this forum suggests is the the objective then it makes no sense to jump ship all the time if the newer trendier cartridge does not do something hugely better than what you already have.
Sadly 99% of gun owners actual believe the dribble that gun writers and OEM's push about short actions being more accurate because they are stiffer! People think they are going to magically get flatter shooting and better accuracy from a shorter case in a shorter action that happens to also be short and fat. This drives sales since it is far cheaper and faster to by a new rifle chambered in the latest trendy thing then it is to buy a boutique barrel, buy a short action or have an existing one blueprinted etc.....Also there is no statistically significant speed advantage to a short action either from a action cycling stand point!
If you already have a 300 Win Mag do you need a 308 Win, 30 Dasher, 300BO, 7.62x54 and 30-06 Spr. and a as well? Prob. not. So then you run into the idea of spreading the love so you do not have too many cartridges with too much over lap.
The only reason I have a 308 Win is for F-T/R my 300 Win mag and 30-06 are lighter and have scopes on that are far better for hunting not target shooting. You run into people that seem to have a fetish for a given bore size or cartridge and they have 7 rifles in 30-06 or 7 rifles all in 30 Cal chamberings. That is not common but we all know someone like that on a gun forum or in real life. I know a guy that collects and restores Yugo's as in the car no idea what he see's in them but he is a great guy if only a tad odd!
Gun makers and ammo makers and some are both have a vested interest in selling you more and more rifles and brass and ammo.
People get bored and want something new from time to time and that is what they are banking on. Well that and that the customer is fairly ignorant and they can get away with anything they want to.
Sadly on some level people know this and choose to ignore it. We have been transformed into a consumer based and service based society! This is why some cartridges just never catch on and on the other hand we have some like the 45-70Govt, 30-06, 8x57, 7x57, 6.5x55 Swede, 7.62x54 Russian that are over a 100 years old and still going strong. The 25-06 is creeping up on 100 years old if you look at it from the 25 Niedner standpoint. There have been a lot of .243 cartridges come and go mostly magnums but the 243 Win is what stuck it is not the fastest one out of all that have come and gone.
If you want to know how often experts are wrong look at egg's, butter, cholesterol, the housing bubble, the fiat currency we use, short actions are stiffer and more accurate, gain twist is more accurate, a tapered bore on a shoulder fired rifle is more accurate, nitrogen filled tires is the only way to go, thinking that man can make water from hydrogen and oxygen, speed of light is a fixed constant, that Maxwell got all his proofs right, low sodium is good for you and in any way linked to health, that heart disease and cholesterol are in any way linked and on and on we can go....Oh that the speed of sound is an invisible barrier in the sky that can not be broken that one is the best!
The 30-06, 308 Win, 30-30 Win, 12ga slug all look terrible on paper but they work great in the real world. The 338 Win Mag looks less than impressive on paper but again it has proven itself in the real world of hunting. If you are hunting not a lot the 338 Edge or 338LM can do for you in terms of hunting that the older slower 338 Win Mag can not already do. If we are looking for anti-material rifle lighter than a 50 BMG rifle than the 338LM is incredible. I do not shoot Elk at 1.75 miles or Elk wearing body armor at 1200m. If I am target shooting though the 338 Win Mag would not be a cartridge I would want to campaign with unless I had no other choice. For better than 20 years I have told people that a 30-06 or 300 Win Mag with a 190gr.-220gr. bullet is more lethal than a 250gr. 338 Win Mag.! The only down side until recently is that most bullets over 190Gr. in 30 Cal where normally a round nose. A lot of bullets over 180gr. that where HPBT where match bullets not intended for hunting.
I think it is comical that companies load the 300 Win Mag. with 150gr. bullets. If you want something that light a 6mm, 6.5mm or 7mm makes more sense. A 308 Win likewise makes more sense in 150gr. than a 300 Win Mag.
Competition demands have infected hunters minds and today they worry about the wrong things when picking a rifle, a chambering and load.
A rifle does not need to make sense or look great on paper if it's primary purpose is to hunt. Man almost wiped out the Buffalo with some pretty crappy cartridges but the buffalo did not seem to care if they where shot with a really anemic cartridge with a trajectory of a rainbow with iron sights they died just the same. Soldiers in the Civil War died at the hands of Sharps, Spencers and Henry rifles shooting a cartridges like the 56-56 Rimfire with an effective range of 500 yards.
If you want a short action chambered in 7mm WSM go for it if that is what you want. You do not need my approval or a group hug just do it. If I think it is the dumbest thing ever it should not matter to you! It is your money and you earned it so do what you will. Do not try to justify it with logic or reasoning. Every time you take it out of the safe smile and enjoy.
That said if you ask peoples opinions on a public forum you should be ready for as many naw's as yaw's but you do not have to accept any of it let alone listen to it!
God Bless and have fun!
Remember shooting should be fun and hunting is about putting meat in the freezer! Everything else is just a distraction!