I'm in the same dilemma as you OP... but I can't take the chance of losing zero or having dialing issues on a hunt of a lifetime... so personally I now own 3 NF SHV's. I really like the discontinued C563 model, the 3-10, moar, non-illum, with parallax adjustment. I have a couple of those and the larger 4-14x56. The big one is NOT light, around 28 oz. I will probably try to find another 3-10 for my upcoming rifle build.
I've also been intrigued by huskemaw...it seems their dialing is great, but i'm not sure about their ruggedness...at least when compared to NF.
I was on a sheep hunt in August, where I got the caribou in my avatar, lugging around my 9.5 lb 7mag with the big NF. Lugging it sucked, but I flew to AK with that rifle, took a bush flight, zero was confirmed perfect. Hiked around for 9 days, shot caribou, bush flight home, 2 airline flights, drove from CO to TN on a deer hunt. Took the rifle out of the case, dialed to 550y, first round impact on the steel we were shooting at. That's the reliability that I will carry a few extra ounces for.