I have five VX-5HD 3-15x44s on lightweight hunting rigs and ARs. All of them perform excellently in regards to optical and mechanical performance. The tracking has been great for consistent impacts to 1000 yards.
I've ran the dials from the zero stop all the way to the top of the elevation travel several times and they all return to zero as they should.
They have nice crisp audible clicks unlike the mushy adjustments from past models and the ZL2 locking mechanism is a nice feature for a woods rifle. Overall, I consider them the best option for for a sub $1000 optic.
For reference, I am not a Leupold supporter. I have a lot of higher end optics like Nightforce, Zeiss, March, and Vortex AMG. I choose to make my own opinions about products and ignore internet lore. I get rid of things that don't work and I haven't gotten rid of any of my VX HD scopes.