I was hoping that was not the case, but now, I see your point - go for it.
It is not worth my oxygen to argue or convince anyone because, as noted ...
Effective Game Killing
- Thread starter FEENIX
- Start date
Help Support Long Range Hunting Forum
It is not worth my oxygen to argue or convince anyone because, as noted ...
Great article, Ive had this one bookmarked for a few years now but his entire website has lots of good reading on calibers and their histories.
As for energy, I still primarily go by [impact] velocity knowing the energy will be there with any common respectable caliber for the game size. Its my understanding that the water in muscle hydraulically opens or mushrooms the bullet and its the speed thats needed to raise the hydraulics enough, perhaps an engineer can correct or compliment that theory. IOW, the energy is needed to penetrate, but its a result of the velocity or rather more simply... most common calibers have way more than enough to worry about energy.
As for energy, I still primarily go by [impact] velocity knowing the energy will be there with any common respectable caliber for the game size. Its my understanding that the water in muscle hydraulically opens or mushrooms the bullet and its the speed thats needed to raise the hydraulics enough, perhaps an engineer can correct or compliment that theory. IOW, the energy is needed to penetrate, but its a result of the velocity or rather more simply... most common calibers have way more than enough to worry about energy.
Effective Game Killing
Effective game killing- How bullets kill and where to aim to ensure a fast clean kill.
www.ballisticstudies.com
Last edited:
dfanonymous
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2016
- Messages
- 2,280
I'm with you!
…and now I'm not. Wut?
How is it the same as torque?
Horsepower is how fast a vehicle can deliver torque ( and some gear efficiency stuff) in max output. It's most definitely not a meaningless number in the auto community. Especially if you're doing dyno testing.
MagnumManiac
Well-Known Member
Oh really. A dyno measures TORQUE.
Horsepower is a mathematical equation using torque and rpm to provide a fictional number. There is no such thing as horsepower.
Cheers.
P.S.
I am a qualified engine builder.
dfanonymous
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2016
- Messages
- 2,280
On which dyno? A chassis dyno rollers can measure both…
Regardless, you're still displaying work, off RPM and torque input to the dyno…doesn't matter if it's through known load or HP/torque crossover at like 5000 rpm.
So if you know how the horse power number is generated, then you know it's a thing…how is it a made up number? That's a circular response..
But what I really want to know it's how torque is like MV related to tissue damage….?
Velocity, energy, and momentum are all terminal numbers that are not made up.
MagnumManiac
Well-Known Member
dfanonymous
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2016
- Messages
- 2,280
Steam engines to horses.
The issue is if it was a made up useless imaginary figure, why is it still used today by engineers in modern cars?
Don't worry. I'll answer that. It's a ubiquitous metric.
Much like velocity, energy and momentum. Metrics. But still, they do not account for bullet construction/design and form factor into the killing equation. None of which is imaginary.
HARPERC
Well-Known Member
I'm not an engineer of any kind. I can say blood flow in the lungs varies, and pools a bit in some situations.
Maybe some day an optic will be able to tell us about where blood/fluid is relative to the shot placement.
So far, for others to help understand energy, shocks, blood flow, shot placement, etc., interrelationships ...
1. A (hydraulic) engineer is required to explain Sir Isaac Newton's Laws (Physics).
2. A medical doctor/forensic scientist.
OMG, I am wondering what else is needed.
@Deputy819, do you know if similar articles are written for "Idiots" or "Dummies"? By the way, I like your energy transfer challenge. 
I am surprised the dead-is-dead guys have not chimed in yet. They are my kind of guys.
1. A (hydraulic) engineer is required to explain Sir Isaac Newton's Laws (Physics).
2. A medical doctor/forensic scientist.
OMG, I am wondering what else is needed.
@Deputy819, do you know if similar articles are written for "Idiots" or "Dummies"?
By the way, I like your energy transfer challenge. I am surprised the dead-is-dead guys have not chimed in yet. They are my kind of guys.
Last edited:
59FLH
Well-Known Member
No idea, and I'm not sure how to calculate it. My MV is LR verified 2596 avg so I assume the BC is lower.
The published data from mfg is:
Bullet length 1.41"
Real World LabRadar verified BC's
275gr =0.36 @ 2800 FPS
My hold over cheat sheet uses the published BC but only goes up to 300yds I put the 4 MOA hash on the top of the shoulder and hit about 4 o'clock just behind. I was shooting from a ladder stand so there's that. If using the published BC @ 2800 is close enough for the KE value like it seemed to be for hold over it can be pulled off any ballistic calculator.
Attachments
Last edited:
59FLH
Well-Known Member
Walter Reed does/did ballistic testing for wound analysis maybe they have open source publicationsSo far, for others to help understand energy, shocks, blood flow, shot placement, etc., interrelationships ...
1. A (hydraulic) engineer is required to explain Sir Isaac Newton's Laws (Physics).
2. A medical doctor/forensic scientist.
OMG, I am wondering what else is needed.
@Deputy819, do you know if similar articles are written for "Idiots" or "Dummies"?
I am surprised the dead-is-dead guys have not chimed in yet. They are my kind of guys.
@331Y (zero altitude, 2596 FPS MV per LR) = ~1841 FPS/2070 FT-LBS
No expert on anything here. Forestry Degree. But I have often wondered how twist rate ie centrifugal force in the bullet relates to bullet upset at impact. Not sure but I think that's the premise for giving the new Blackout an extremely fast twist of 1 x 3" as with subsonic velocity is lacking. If spinning one fast enough will make it disintegrate in mid air. I would think it would have to have some effect at impact.
