I plugged your info in real quick to iStrelok and it's showing 3.66MOA up so still pretty close, within 1 click.I have checked, and rechecked the information numerous times, and nothing lines up. This Grendel is a 1/4 moa rifle. I can shoot bullet drops, measure them, adjust my scope for said drops, and it's spot on. I just can't get the ballistic calculators to line up with the ballistics of the rifle. I have the same problem with my other rifles. I have a Remington 700 long range in 300WM, and I run into the same problem with it.
Double check your info in my pics and post yours' up so we can troubleshoot it.