first i am not trying to fight with you, we all have our opinions, but i just want to respond to a few comments.
Glad to hear your side.
i suppose there has never been a non-union worker who has done this?
The story I mentioned was the most egregious example I could remember but it reflected the overall attitude of a lot of the steel workers and miners (mostly steel workers) that I came in contact with. Like I said before, not all the guys were like this, but there was an attitude with a lot of guys of getting paid for doing little to nothing. A worker in a non-union shop or mill would have been sent home without pay or fired. My point being that the union protected such behaivior and that is a fact. It was almost impossible to fire a union worker.
i am an ironworker in pittsburgh, i have been "black listed" but it dosen't matter. we can solicit ourt own work, so technically i don't need the union hall to get me work, just my reputation. those who can preform get the work period. i have seen many guys starve out and quit or move on. building trades, like i stated earlier, has no immunity. if you can't work you can't stay. we typically work with hard dollar bids, and if we don't make the contractor money, he will not bid work with us again.
i was born to go against the grain. it hasen't affected my ability to get enough credit hours, nor many thousands of other union tradesmen.
So it sounds to me like there was some politics going on your union hall that you did not go along with and you were black listed for it although you did good enough work to find jobs based on your rep. This is part of what I'm talking about. I don't know much about the iron workers as most of my experience and contact is with steel workers and miners and some masons and teamsters. My iron worker friend was/is also able to get work but at the same time he felt like he was not getting a fair deal. He had his differences with his union hall and they were doing whatever to punish or bring him in line. Don't know the details but last I talked with him he was considering quitting and finding something else to do but so far hasn't to the best of my knowledge.
this is completely wrong. i have never seen a good hard working guy in my buisiness held back. our work is word of mouth. if someone is good he will be on my hire list. why would i want dead weight on my jobs. i want to look good so i surround myself with good workers.
I don't know what your shop was like but like I said, my friend felt like he was being held back to some degree and not getting the opportunities he thought he was entitled to. Other guys I've talked in the trades have told me flat out that they were not to work too hard or accomplish too much. You lay "X" number of brick and block a day and no more. A self employed mason would lay 12" block by himself and union masons used 2 bricklayers to lay 12" block, according to the rules. I was looking at getting on with a mason's union when I was young but after talking with a few laborers and mason's, I decided it wasn't for me. IMO they had an anti-motivation attitude and work environment and exercised much too much personal/job site control over an individual.
i bet your employees would like that. sure would feel good to be able to afford something.
apparently your employees make next to nothing, just a few bucks above min wage.
you can always not bid those jobs.
You bet they would like that. They would like getting $100/hour even better. I paid my employees the going rate for their skills in this area period, which was well above minimum wage. If a job went well I gave them bonuses. I also gave them raises based on their productivity, and I fired a few based on same. Reward for good work and motivation to do good work. And no, I did not bid on many of those jobs and only got one. I did not care to put up with the bureaucratic BS. Not worth it.
The bottom line is that the cost of the project is going to go up under Davis-Bacon with no increase in quality. So that cost is passed along to the client who then passes it along to his clients and customers. That is not competition. That is government meddling in the free market. It is a socialist mindset and it is exactly what makes America less competitive in the global market, and it is exactly what drives jobs outside our borders along with all the other government meddling that the unions support. Both need to be put in check.
Be safe and don't fall off any sky scrapers.