Bullet performance is dependent on design, yes, but it also changes with impact velocity.
I get the sense that your criticisms here relate to 'normal' range hunting, yet on the first page you answered '700-800yds'.
Meat waste is mainly a shot placement thing but
Yes, shoot a soft bullet at high velocity, and it can make a real mess up close.
On impacts above 3000fps, that's where some of the new generation monos really shine.
Under 2400fps, Cup and Core is really in its element.
Its about picking the right tool for the job. Some guys understand this and carry two different loads - one for close and one for far.
Like
@dogz said - put the bullet in a good spot, and good things happen.
Hit the spine with speed, and yer goona mess up some backstrap.
In the past, when hunting for meat, I've passed up on quartering shots that looked like I might poke the guts or blow up a shoulder.
I've seen an Elk shoulder catch a .338 225gr ELD-X. CATCH - meaning it never made it through the ribs and into the vitals.
From what I have seen personally, and what's been shared on this site, I feel ELD-Xs are MORE explosive than Berger's.
Ultimately, I believe bullets that are good for up close are not good for distance. Bullets built for LR have some tradeoffs when used in close. Explosive performance can be mitigated with shot placement (i.e. shoot ribs in ribs out)
As I suggested in post #2, if looking for a bullet that performs from 0-1000, there are goona be some trade offs.
I like having the ability to reach out, but also acknowledge that statistically my 'average' shot on big game is about 150yds, so I choose accordingly.
Good luck with your choice, and happy shooting