johnlittletree
Well-Known Member
I like the 280 idea but the AI part that is not remotely a good idea in 2018 almost 2019. That would be like recommending a magneto system and Holly carburetor on a daily driver in a cold climate in 2018. In 2018 nothing is a bigger waste of resources for a modern rifle especially for hunting than AI modifications. We have too many cases to choose from today we have no need to do the AI thing. Are you trying to be romantic or just too old and too in love with AI cases.The minimum cartridge size in my opinion would be the 280 AI and go up from there for the heavy 7mm bullets. The middle of the road choice would be a 7mm STW On the big end the 7 RUM would be my top choice. There are other choices but you would have to decide which one based on your needs/wants.
Just My opinion
J E CUSTOM
In fact with today's powders if you did a head to head using modern powders in a standard 280 and did an AI using only powder and bullet designs that Ackley had available when he developed his modified cartridge the standard 280 with modern hi end powders bullets would win. Just because something is old and requires a lot of tinkering to get right does not make it a good thing!
If he is building a rifle from scratch and is not limited to 280 and it is not powerful enough the next logical step is not AI it is a larger standard cartridge like the 7mm Rem Mag just as an example. If he does not want a belt than doing with a 7mm what we do with the 338 Edge would likewise make sense. Life is too short to spend all your free time modifying when you do not have to.
I do not understand why so many people on this sight can not bring themselves to exercise logic, math and science and use readily available cartridges that a proven to do the job.
I know I say this often but you usually can not hunt international with wildcats because the rifle has to be proofed and the head stamp on the brass has to match the chambering. Since ZERO brass comes head stamped in AI cartridges that is that. On top of that but the same holds true for competition in many countries.
7mm STW was kind of a joke 20 years ago because it burns through barrels and powder in a hurry. I guess if you need to shoot a deer or Elk 2 miles away it might be useful! LOL It is kind of like putting a V8 in a riding lawn mower you can do it but it makes no sense! It amazes me that for the last 200 years people have harvested animals for food with out AI cartridges for the most part and made war with their neighbors again nothing as silly as AI cartridges! LOL
If you look at what has harvested the most medium to large game in the last 100 years in North America it not going to be a boutique cartridge. It would be 30-06, 308, 30-30, 270, 338 Win Mag, 8mm Mauser, 7mm Mauser, 6.5x55, 243, 25-06, 300 Win Mag, 7mm Rem Mag, 7mm-08, 350 Rem Mag, 458 Lott, 35 Whelen. Barring the 458 Lott and the 35 Whelen you can buy the above at Walmart, KMart, Meijers most gas stations in the middle of no where so long as you have farming and hunters coming through.
In the last 30 years so many cartridges have been developed that it truly is silly to do an AI today. Do you guys get points or pats on the back for killing a beast with a more obscure cartridge or having a rifle that no one wants because it is manual case prep, fire forming and reloading only? If that is the case you guys should maybe do an AI version of a 10.15x61mmR. Now if you can shoot Prong Horn or Elk at 1000m with that that would be impressive!LOL
I am just glad Mr. P.O. Ackley left the 45-70 alone and the 22LR and 22 Short alone! You would think that if his idea's whee so great more of his cartridges would have been made into standards instead of remaining Wild Cat's.