308 enough for brown/polar bear?

[FEENIX]

I wanted to get a 375 H&H but at the time I didn't know how well I would be able to shoot it. When I finally got to shoot one heck it seemed easier than my 45-70 with hot loads lol.

My .45-70 might be too long for bear defense.

 

[xsn10s]

My .45-70 might be too long for bear defense.
View attachment 603856

Yup mine has an 18" barrel. Fast and light. It had a VariXIII 1.5-5 on it at the time. But one day even though I trained alot with it I found it left on 5X. I was so mad at myself I idiot proofed it, and it now has a Leupold M8 fixed 2.5X on it.

 

[pavementends]

While a "battle rifle" would be a comfort in a bear attack I would think it would interfere with other activities. I one is hunting you would have a supposedly adequate rifle in your hands. If fishing, camping, cleaning a downed animal a .308 large capacity rifle is awkward. You are the only one who has to be comfortable with whatever you decide. If the worst happens and you were correct you get to brag if you were wrong we get to read about it.

 

[Web1350]

LOL he still killed a griz with a 9mm lol.

Probably died from lead poisoning. Lol

 

[Ol' Red]

My .45-70 might be too long for bear defense.
View attachment 603856

You can shove that in his mouth from a ways out. Can't miss then.

 

[69precision]

308 would certainly be way better than any pistol.

 

[unirove]

308 would certainly be way better than any pistol.

Like this Short, light, fast. BAR MK 3

<snip>
18" fluted barrel Turkish walnut stock. Detachable box magazine, lightweight alloy receiver with Picatinny rail scope base and a proven reliable piston gas system."

</snip>

 

[xsn10s]

My .45-70 might be too long for bear defense.
View attachment 603856

Nice 1886 btw.

 

[DUCKMAN11]

I think there is too much dogma and misinformation surrounding this topic, and the internet is full of both.

I see people advocating for pump shotguns or nothing, and never for semi auto shotguns. They say in freezing conditions the semi auto of any kind becomes unreliable, but plenty of duck hunters use semi auto shotguns in nasty conditions just fine because that was what they were designed for. An easy way to screw up a fixed mechanical system is to introduce a human element, so someone panicking and trying to pump a shotgun through cold and adrenaline seems like a good way to reach a failure point.

People talk big bore revolvers which are hard to shoot. They say the caliber has to start with a 4 or whatever yet the empirical data shows that most handguns are effective. There is this warm fuzzy feeling people get when they talk about revolvers as though they were the pinnacle of simplicity and reliability when really it just seems that we as a community have forgotten all the problems like timing issues etc that revolvers had.

I did watch a youtube video where someone was advocating for a semi auto .308 as a dangerous game type gun for north America. I think the real advantage he spoke on was is simply capacity and how it pertains to overall firepower. You can fit a 25 round magazine of .308 into a Ruger SFAR for example which makes a pretty powerful yet lightweight packages which is probably a dream to shoot compared to a big bore lever gun.

All hypothetical though. I really think that this topic is beaten to death, and that if a big bear really wants to kill you, you aren't going to have time to react.

I've seen semi auto shotguns freeze up or get sluggish duck hunting in Texas....I can only imagine how bad it could get in polar bear country. Usually happens from way too much remoil or hoppes dumped in the action and usually it was a Benelli

 

[brcfo_outdoors]

I've seen semi auto shotguns freeze up or get sluggish duck hunting in Texas....I can only imagine how bad it could get in polar bear country. Usually happens from way too much remoil or hoppes dumped in the action and usually it was a Benelli

Wouldn't know I shoot Berettas lol.

 

[DUCKMAN11]

Wouldn't know I shoot Berettas lol.

Same here! And use them to paddle boats and break ice, club water moccasins. I've never found a full size shell it wont shoot! Dropped mine in that black suck mud and washed it out with the water it fell in. They haven't let me down in 23 years of West Texas Mars dust quail hunting or east Texas gumbo mud. As far as semiauto shotguns are concerned.....Beretta is the pinnacle.