As this thread keeps popping up on my e-mail since I gave a prior response, it forced me to think s a bit more about the reasons why ai have used a 200 yard zero for about the last ten years......when I extended my hunting range to 1000 yards(or so). Again, I wouldn't die on any hill over using a 100 or 200 yard zero, but these are my perceptions..
-In reality, where the zero is set doesn't prohibit you from testing your zero at any range you choose if you have confirmed dopes. Setting the zero at 200 can make a 5-10% difference in turret or reticle traveled-riding on your particular set-up. With my primary hunters, I am able to stay within one turret revolution for over 90% of my hunting shots for the last several years. Not a big deal, but an attractive benefit, particularly in the heat of the moment. Fortuitously, with my primary hunter, a 200 yard zero in my average conditions, my from 200-1000 yards are easier values to commit to memory, and make adjustments(MOA) for distance or condition changes....mentally. 200yd=0, 300yd=2.0, 400=4.0, 500=6.5, 600=9.0, 700=12.0, 800=15.0, 900=18.0, 1000=21.5. These are easier values to deal with compared to my 100 yard fractional values. I actually tune my loads to confirm these values at my standard conditions.
-At 200 yards, I find myself checking my rifle zero "and" my zero. I always check my zero from stable hunting or competition positions. Since switching to a 200 yard zero I'm surprised at how many of my .5MOA rifles became .25MOA rifles, a result of 200 yard conditioning, and frequency. A 200 yard zero forces me to concentrate much harder on the shot, consider wind(which can also effect a 100 yard zero), and make sure all form and settings are exact. While it may not be material for a lot of hunting shots, my standard of performance from myself and my rifle has increased. This can make a difference for the longer shots.
-Even with the much famed high end, high power scopes we use for LRH, I find the parallax adjustment at 100 yards far more sensitive at 100 yards then at 200 yards and believe the mind boggling zero shifts in 100 yard zero's are many times due to this factor.
-It's purely psychological, but confidence is everything. When I look at a 100 yard group and multiply it 10X when I think about a 1000 yard shot on a big buck, I find it much more confidence building to multiply my very tight 200 yard group 5x for the same shot. It's also nice to see 100 and 200 yard groups the same size.
Just some thoughts.
Zeros: 200 Yards(left:aiming point grid cross); right 100 Yard. Prone, bipod/rear bag. These are better then average.....but..., usually shooting .25MOA with this rifle.