The 17 HMR has a big rainbow trajectory especially if you are shooting out to 300 yards. There are some reticle designs that will get you out to 300 yards but my concern would be that you aren't going to like the in between distances where there are no marks. For example, I think the ballistic plex gives you hold marks for 150, 200, 250, and 300 yards. But if you are shooting small target like prairie dogs at an in between distance I am not sure how well you are going to like that reticle. If I were going to go with a reticle for the 17 HMR I would look at a graduated hash reticle in 1/2 MIl or 1 or 1 MOA so you have lots of hold points.
Like you mentioned dialing may be the better option just because you can dial for what ever distance your target is and the have an exact hold point. So I personally would look at t graduated reticle or dial but wouldn't look at the BDC styles. That is just me though.
I have a Weaver V16 on mine. They are very nice scopes. Excellent reputations for durability, and turret repeatability. Their glass is very nice, especially for the price. Their turrets are semi target so you get the target feel with MOA and click marks shown on the turret in a compact package. One of my very favorite scopes for rimfire and small centerfire arms.
HTH,
Scot E.