I've ran all sorts of tires, most all the ones mentioned, and this winter I tried the General Grabber AT2 tires after reading hours of reviews and being highly recommended by two of my friends. Bottom line - I will never buy another tire besides the General Grabber AT2 again in my life, I'm sold on them. I put them on my Toyota pickup and I'll be putting them on my Suburban come this next winter. You don't hear them at all, and they are scary good on ice. We have alot of icy roads here in Colorado and for the first week I left the four wheel drive off and just drove in two wheel drive when I know everybody else was in 4x4. The reason I said scary good was because I was driving 10 miles an hour faster than everybody else in two wheel drive and those tires never slipped once. I knew they had to at some point, and that is why I called them scary good - but never a slip once. Super great on ice and snow, no problems in the mud I've been in, and you can't hear them - no road noise and they are a good looking tire. I never read a bad review and I read hundreds of them, that says something to me. The best part, they're cheap to buy - I put 31x10.5 x15 tires on the Toyota and they cost me $123.00 each. I'll never buy anything else again, just hope they don't stop making them for the rest of my life. Check them out - you won't be disappointed, I guarantee it. The only thing I can't vouch for is longevity as I've probably only put 12,000 miles on them, but I have a ton of life left on them - I expect I'll easily get 50,000 miles before they need replaced. One more thing, probably half my driving is to oil well locations, generally bad roads, not maintained very well, and usually steep. I ran this winter half as much in four wheel drive as I normally do, just because of those tires - I'm telling you, they're unbelievably good.