Tumbling Recipe?

Joined
Nov 14, 2024
Messages
8
Location
Virginia
I just picked up a Rotary Tumbler and tried to tumble some 300 wsm once fired brass last night with water, stainless steel pins and Franklin brass cleaner. Tumbled for about 2-3 hours, rinsed and dried it and it came out pretty dull. Any tips of how to get it shiny?
 
I use a Rebel 17 high speed brass tumbler. They recommend Dawn and LemShine. A half teaspoon of LemShine is plenty IMO. Used together, my brass always looks good. I could tumble until they are shinier but that removes the carbon from the inside of the necks and tends to ding up the case mouths. Tumbling for 30min (max) gets the job done and makes the brass look good.
 
Sometimes if it's dull you need to change out the solution. Then tumble for a little bit after the clean water change and whatever else you add. I think sometimes it's like changing mop water. Sometimes it just gets too dirty to make whatever you are cleaning clean.
 
I just picked up a Rotary Tumbler and tried to tumble some 300 wsm once fired brass last night with water, stainless steel pins and Franklin brass cleaner. Tumbled for about 2-3 hours, rinsed and dried it and it came out pretty dull. Any tips of how to get it shiny?
Tumbled too long , hour and a half with a micro shot of Dawn and a dash of Lemi shine with hot water then I follow up with a vibratory, Tumblr walnut hull media and white diamond metal polish for another hour and a half.
IMG_3284.jpeg
 
I just picked up a Rotary Tumbler and tried to tumble some 300 wsm once fired brass last night with water, stainless steel pins and Franklin brass cleaner. Tumbled for about 2-3 hours, rinsed and dried it and it came out pretty dull. Any tips of how to get it shiny?
I'm old fashioned. I use crushed walnut shells and any abrasive thick liquid automotive polish in a vibratory tumbler. Works like a champ in an hour or so every time. It even made 50+ yr old 30-06 Match brass look like new.
 
Zoom in on the primer pockets, you will see a black dot that is not dirt. That is a reflection of the flash hole.
 
I use the Frankfort Arsenal wet tumbler.

Hot water out of the tap, as hot as it gets (1/2-3/4 full). A pan of almost boiling water.

1 tablespoon of Lemie-shine

4 squirts of Dawn Power Wash.

2 cap fulls of car wash soap.

Small/medium brass 1-2 hours. Large/Lapua size brass 2-3 hours. After I'm done washing and rinsing, I'll hit them with the air compressor. Then I set them in the oven at 200 and shake every 15 minutes (1 hour). I leave the top of the oven door cracked.
IMG_4932.jpeg

6.5-284

66267974732__A3A791B9-5E6B-4276-BB14-04C5DDC9F01F.jpeg

338 Lapua
 
Last edited:
Never been a fan of super shinny squeaky clean brass. Just a hour or so in vibratory tumbler with untreated walnut shells for me. My only goal is to get them clean for the sizing die. Cleaned not polished. I've never wanted to remove all traces of carbon from inside the necks as I have always felt that this helps in seating bullets and improves accuracy.
 
Wet tumbling OF ANY TYPE will not give you shiny brass. Tumble it in walnut media or corn cob media for an hour or so after you wet tumble (and dry, of course) and you will get shiny brass.

After the dry tumbling you will be able to see the damage to the brass necks that is done by wet tumbling. (Couldn't help throwing that in).
 
Top