Interesting discussion thanks for kicking it off.
I've been hunting elk for 42 years, over that time I've take enough to fill up an ark and have been in on many more (up in the triple digits). So naturally I have a few thoughts. First off not all elk hunts are equal. We have true DIY on public land, guided on public land, guided on private, border bulls (where one haunts the borders or big ranches waiting for one to cross), mountain and wilderness hunts, hay field farm hunts, black timber, open big country and so on.
Point being we have a ton load different ways to go about elk hunting. I've always been a DIY on public ground kind of guy allow with some public dark timber in late November. As such, we have many ways of toting our rifles around. Being as I'm always the mule (or at least so says my wife
I'm the one carrying anything that goes up or down the mountain. As such weight is important to me!
My elk rifles need to be sub 9 lbs "all up" meaning sling, rounds, scope, bipod. I refuse to carry anymore and the most of them go without the bipod and go sub 8 "all up". Now I've found I can go too light and it won't be able to settle down when it's time to go. And anymore it's getting more and more rare for me to carry a bipod, for the ranges I go to I can get it done via laying over a pack frame just fine.
Speaking of time to go, depending on what kind of elk hunt you're doing the term time to go can and does have a lot off variances to it. That said, I've generally found I just don't have time to muck around much if at all. So, for me taking the time to put on shooting muffs/ plugs etc just isn't in the cards. That said, I refuse to use a braked rifle, my hearing isn't what it used to be but the brakes I've been around have been horrendous when it comes to shooting them without protection. Plus the one's I've been around have been bad to sitting to the side of as an observer as well. Perhaps though they like most things have gotten better with time and research.
One thing I should point out is that I'm not what one would call a true long range shooter. I practice to 700 and that's it for me. I've taken and have seen a ton load of elk taken in the 400-700 range. I want a rifle that is user friendly, makes my weight requirements and does it sub braked.
I don't worry near as much about seeing the bullet hit the critter as I do being able to hit the turf and get 3 onto a pie plate in sub 10 seconds out to 700. . If I get to hear the bullet hit the critter that's a plus. But spotting the hit generally doesn't happen. Perhaps if I was shooting at longer ranges or would work with a brake it would happen.
Now what I do like is to see the reaction to the hit, that's where certain rounds come in handy on elk. But that's different from seeing the spot where the bullet hit the elk. This also why I like the big 7's so much. They can be shot from most all positions with no fear of wearing the scope and they take down large big game like elk very well. I'm aware of the love for the RUM's on tis forum but I can't say I've ever seen one in the mountains or elk camps that I attend. I had a real thing for the 300 RUM for some time, some of the fella's I guided toted them and when I was around them at the range they were incredibly accurate. If one can handle them uffda what elk killing machines they are!
The big 30's and the big 33's are wonderful elk killing machines, but for the weight I like my elk rigs to be they just aren't in the cards anymore (I did wear out two Scheider 340 barrels on guns that weight a bit over 8).
Long and the short or this long winded post....I just want to encourage all to get in shape and hit the hills for elk no matter what you carry. We never get the time back!