• If you are being asked to change your password, and unsure how to do it, follow these instructions. Click here

Recent grizzly attacks on Montana elk hunters

Better to have something than nothing, there isn't a handgun that's adequate to stop a charging grizz with one shot without hitting grey matter, most rifles won't drop them in their tracks. Carry whatever your comfortable with, and keep a few prayers in the mag, if you have to pull a pistol on a charging grizzly, those prayers are your best bet.

This is a long range hunting site, and we all know why we do everything we can to reduce recoil in our rifles...... It's so we can hit stuff with them. Same goes for handguns, but even worse, a flinch with a short barreled handgun can result in a miss by several feet when shooting at targets that are less than 20 yards away. I shoot as many or more rounds out of my handguns every year than I do my rifles and can assure you that it takes more practice to become a good shot with a pistol than it does a rifle. A long range rifle requires more technical knowledge, but a handgun requires more shots down range imo, I suppose some of that depends on what your naturally good at....but....I can hand my rifle to someone who has never shot one before and have them hit a plate at 200 yards the first time they pull the trigger, and then have the same person shoot a pistol at a refrigerator box at 20ft and miss the whole box.

If you can shoot big handguns well, it's a great option for you......If you can't, let's face it....your bear food, so leave your 10mm at home and fill your pockets with berries so you taste good.
 
Yes, very sad deal.
Likely a training issue, no gun does you any good if you don't know how to use it and have it readily available. Not shots were fired, there was nothing wrong with the gun, there wasn't a round in chamber if I'm not mistaken.
 
A grizzly is a lot bigger than a male lion. It can move as fast over short distance. It has longer claws, and equal teeth. It's not as stealthy as a lion, but in bear habitat, they are easier to stumble upon accidentally.

I've never heard of anyone carrying a handgun as backup for lion.
 
Looking at the power class of a 10mm on average your going to have to run three rounds into a bear to equal one 454 Casual in energy, it's not going to have the penetration capability either.
 
Holy cow Nancy, he was packing a 10mm semi auto, sorry I assumed when talking about a 10mm it being in a semi auto package since that's what 99 percent of 10mms are in, there are some exceptions but the norm is semi.
 
That was guide Mark Uptain I believe. From the reports there was never even a round chambered in the 10mm.
Nope, he set it down with his pack and the client could not or did not know how to use it since he had no training, he simply could not pull it out and pull the trigger.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 5 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top