Gday quintus
That's a great discussion right there in your post above & if you or others would like to dabble in hypotheticals I'm all in
So on the outside looking in & a little assumption on our parts & just take a touch off your 236 load so not inflating one against the other
& Using old thumb rule of 100 fps per 10 gr
The following seem fairly realistic
The 210 @3350
The 220 @3250
The hypothetical 235 @ 3100
Now add the part of a bear with a arrow in it & oh how I'm out of my depth here
Which needs to be despatched asap & as quickly as possible ( 2 different things in my mind )
So this would be a frontal shot & one that needs to knock the stuffing out of him quick really quick ( no delayed killing here would be wanted )
So this gives us some parameters to work with or should say towards & in my mind the following applies
Range :
be 5 to 50 yard on outside chance of following up a hit bear & it erupts from 50 yard
( once again huge assumption on my part but trying for conversation & hypothetical) so range would be from there & in
Velocity impact :
This leaves us with ea pill loosing around 2fps per yard as a yardstick
So 10 to 100 fps for the 5 &50 yard mark
Now we get into the depths of impacts & what they do to critters & once again broadly speaking as it ultimately comes down to pill design & characteristics that will give us our true results of a pill's capabilities
So I'll leave this for a second & go to the next part as without looking @ this first it dosent matter how fast or slow you impact your potentially in for a world of hurt real quickly
So it's onto
Penertration requirements :
You put stem to stern on a 9ft bear
Which I assume the following you'll need around 40 in of penertration to reach the gut on a frontal but I don't like to just reach I want more as compression comes in here & the last 1/4 to 1/3 of total penertration is basically useless in a wound channel as the best work it will do is in the firs 2/3 to 3/4 of penertration capabilities
So I want 50 in total penertration
So can the pills named above give that
I can only work on what I've seen & saw information with a great guy that helped me gather information on the 210 hht & on those tests recently
We found penetration capabilities of 31in & fairly tough resistance in some of that length with the shank & couple petals @ that length showing no real slowdown in the shanks speed ( it will have , just still gave a nice wound channel ) so I'm going to assume it would get close to to the 50 in mark for total penetration or close to it
So that being the lightest & if the other 2 pills behave exactly the same ( which I highly doubt ) all 3 are going to give adequate penertration so no clear winner here & now need to go back to the velocity impact
So on these numbers I'll put a x through the 235 as it's impact will be around 3000 while no slouch it will potentially show a slight less critter reaction & when you impact @3200 plus things just step up another notch ( a balanced pill for that application is still paramount not just speed)
So leaves me with the 210&220 as those will be around that 3200 plus mark impact but the 210 has it covered @the 50 yard mark no doubt
So the next part of the equation is why not lighter again & get to 3500 plus impacts
I'd be extremely conservative on this approach on the big nasty critters & need to do some pretty extensive testing before I'd be happy to even contemplate that idea in this hypothetical case as I'm assuming that penertration would be lessened a fair bit & back to the 3 ft total penetration length with a 180ish weight pill to get 3600 MV to get to those 3500 impact levels
That's based off the capability's of the 175hh & 205ph shank weights but is definitely only a theory base & was just to get people ticking on a application of merit to one's specific requirements & I do believe over penetration is definitely better than under especially with these guys more so
& lastly once again I've got no idea on bears so I'd love to delve a little deeper/further so I can understand what you guys are up against & I may be able to relate another critters terminal results in a better format than I just put up in my head as I'm totally @ sea with bears
Eg a big cat needs velocity to shut them down quickly & you put a big slow meplat into one & fair chance he will make it to you to say gday
unless cns is impacted
So do bears react the same
or is it a knock the locomotion out like is best on elephant
( I don't think so ) or a combination like on buff
or something else as these bears intrigue me a fair bit ( that's follow up like in this example of quintas but still has similar traits to normal shots imo )
Looking forward if anyone wants to chew the fat & school me better on bears
Cheers