Let's leave out the controversies from the post and assume this is by experts with appropriate practice.
I guess some choose to reply to threads without ever reading the request or content of the OP's first post. Or if they do they choose to ignore it without a consideration of who else might want to have an adult discussion or learn practices and technique.
The thing that I have a hard time with is someone comes on here like a self appointed hall monitor to look down on others or how they choose to set their goals and accomplishments. And then take for granted they have more compassion for a game animal than the next guy. I for one have been on here enough to feel that most all, or at least a very high percentage, of the people here are not wanting to wound an animal in any way. Yes, I do believe we all have the moral sense, compassion and love for game to want clean kills and a fast dispatch. Wounded animals are very unfortunate, but unfortunately this is a reality of hunting. We all have had one where we wish it would have been a faster kill. For me that just happened to be close and personal in timber at 50 yards. It can happen at any distance, with any type of hunting firearm. If you can't deal with that , maybe look into a different sport. These unfortunate mishaps make most all hunters strive to do better, and we do. So please don't come on a long range hunting site, and into the ELR forum and preach to the adults here. Why not try giving the people interested in ELR the space to discuss it without your imposed personal limitation or choices clouding the discussions. Chances are many will learn, and understand the difficulties while practicing and realize their own personal limits without the help of a self appointed dictator.
I personally asked Len for this forum. He thought long and hard and consulted experts in the field before making it a reality. I feel he understands that education is a good thing. But it is seldom useful to just be negative in either teaching or learning.
I don't know if I will ever take a mile plus shot at game. I don't even have the rifle I choose to do it with yet. But if and when I choose to try it, and if all the condition and stars align, I will be the one to make the call. It is no different than the shaky beginner with a buck at 100 yards. Should he not shoot? If so maybe he never should? We all took that first shot once, I am sure glad we didn't have someone there preaching "wounded animal" and talking us out of it. If so maybe we would not be part of the great sport of hunting no matter what the method of harvest.
Respectfully.
Jeff