I think with some people, the high-dollar gear gives them more confidence in shooting. For me, it was not this way. I grew up shooting old scopes, low magnification, iron sights, cheap(ish) guns, etc...And learning how to make it work.
I am just as confident with my old $100 Tasco World Class & 7mm-08 Ruger 77 tang-safety, as I am with my Weatherby Mark V AccuMark .257 Wby, or Rem 700 Sendero SF 7mmSTW with Zeiss' sitting on top of them.
I can kill a deer the same amount of dead with a $100 Tasco as I can shooting my A-Bolt with a $1,500 Kahles sitting on it. For the record I acquired the scope used, in a trade with a buddy of mine, there is no way I could ever afford a $1,500 scope on my salary...
Confidence is confidence. And I can understand the whole, "buy good once, and not cheap once, then expensive the next time around, and learn your lesson..." But the fact is...A good shot is a good shot is a good shot. Doesn't matter what name is on your gear.
So I can understand both parts of the arguement. And I am definitely not one to snob someone at the range because they have a Bushnell / Rem 710 combo from Wally World that cost $300.....Although I have shot a couple of those, and none of them would hit the broad side of a barn...But that's besides the point...As long as they're happy with their gear, and they're enjoying shooting, don't judge or criticize them b/c their gear didn't cost as much as yours did, or b/c their rifle is a factory gun, and yours is a tack-driving custom build. I got lucky that all my factory rifles are tack-drivers, and didn't need any custom work done. However, my Smith takes good care of me, and takes care of me on my prices too, b/c he knows I'm not one of his more "well off" customers with deep pockets.... And yes, he is so good at what he does, he has people paying him over $5K for custom rifles... I get ALOT more for my money when I go to him. He's just a good guy, and treats every gun the same as if it were his own. So, if he likes you, and he knows you well, he's gonna always go above and beyond what all you ask him to do. For example, with my last custom I simply paid him to do a barrel swap with a used barrel he had laying around. He only charged me $265 for the barrel, and all the work involved in swapping and truing the barrel. Then he re-bedded the action, floated the barrel, tuned my trigger, cut the barrel to my desired length, re-crowned w/ an 11* match crown, and completely trued the whole rifle up.... For the $265 he charged me... That's what kind of guy he is. And that is why I have used him for the last 11 years. Then the rifle got stolen back in 2008, and I haven't had the money to have him build another one. I'm still sick about that...
Good gear doesn't mean that it costs you 1/4 of your yearly salary to buy it. The $500 scopes of today, are 10x better than the $1,500 scopes of 10 years ago.
I have some cheap gear, and I have some nice high dollar gear. But I am just as confident with either in my hand... I know I can shoot, and it doesn't matter what the names on the gear says when it's in my hands....Whatever I'm shooting at, is dead. And you can bet your last dollar on that.
However, with all that being said, if I could afford to replace all my scopes with NF, S&B, Swaro, etc.....You think I wouldnt? I'd do it in a heartbeat.
Better glass is better glass...Hands down. But just b/c something doesn't say your favorite name brand, doesn't mean it deserves to be immediately throwin into the scrap bin.
I see everyone's points on here, and I agree with all of yall. I'm just glad yall can put up with my rambling ***..... Sorry, I get bored behind my desk....