Well, if future elk is in the mix, and light recoil is a plus, I too think either the 6.5 Creedmoor ( better would be the 6.5/284 or a 260 AI) or 7mm08. For elk I'd try 120gr TTSX in both calibers (6.5 or 7mm) and the 120NBT for deer. Either the Camilla, compact Tikka or Lady Hunter would be my pick too, just not sure what calibers they come in. The Tikka T3 Lite SS comes in .270....no flies on this old jewel for either recoil or elk killing! I've had phenomenal accuracy with the 110 TTSX in my .270 and very little recoil. I think all the others mentioned come in 7mm08....I can guarantee you a .308 carbine kicks all in your face, wow! ( Ruger Ultralight, 20"bbl .308= brutal deer killer! ha) The reason I said 6.5/284 is I had one made up in a SA back in the 90's. I had a Mod 700 SA and had a Midway A&B 6.5 260 short chambered barrel put on. Smith reamed it to the 6.5/284 and I put a wood "Classic" stock on it. I only shot the 120 & 125 Nosler BTs and PTs in it. It was a deer killer deluxe! Runs with a 240 Weatherby ( which Weatherby is coming out or is out a Camilla Mark V) Lots of good choices.