I've never been on a guided hunt. This conversation is enlightening for me. I guess I don't understand the idea of tipping for a service that has already charged me for the service I'm receiving. If the guide requires or deserves more money , why don't they charge up front . I seldom ever took a tip from a customer when I was an archery tech . The few times I did, it was to keep from offending the customer . For me a thank you is all the extra I wanted . I see the point in tipping a waiter/waitress . Their paycheck is dependant on tips and its understood. I dont get the tipping thing in a business that charges fully for a service rendered .
All that said, I guess I will have to take into account that a guided trip doesn't really cost what is charged , but actually costs 10% or more over the advertised price . That is , if I ever go on such a hunt . I would have likely thanked them graciously and given them a nice knife to remember the hunt. Like I said, enlightening .