I just finished searching the site for products for cleaning the carbon out of a poorly maintained rifle. I was asked if I would mount a scope for a friend and when I was sighting it in it shot like a scatter gun. I brought it home and bore scoped the barrel and as another friend described it look like a tire that went flat for 25 miles .I have been cleaning it out and the question I have is how much carbon build up is acceptable?
The gun is a 1960's vintage Winchester. According to the owner it was his fathers gun and does not know if it was ever cleaned.
Another question, the barrel and lands look stepped in somewhat even increments for the full length of the barrel, any ideas.
I have tested most of the cleaners and lubes over the last 2 years and spent a bunch of money doing it. Ive seen barrels recently so cartooned out that rifling was barely visible. These barrels were of foreign military rifles that a friend has. He complained of bad groups and said he cleaned it until clean patches came out using Hoppes. On a bet I won a few bucks telling him it wasn't clean. I scoped the bore and it was horrendous. Heavy copper on top of carbon. I'd have to say it was fired with undersized bullets for it to build up like that. So here is what I have found to be the best cleaners and CLP's. Bore Tech were good but for normal carbon removal, Flitz LIQUID polish is awesome and my go to cleaner. For really heavy stuff as mentioned above, KG2 bore polish is the best. I know JB is popular but it is a pain to get out and KG2 cleans out much easier. I wrap a patch around a nylon brush and soak with KG2 and go at it. KG2 cleaned my friends bore and rifling was visible when done. I follow up with Prolix CLP to clean out KG or Flitz and provide a dry film lube and rust preventative in the bore.
In the CLP category, Prolix and Adiga Armory CLP's are the best. Both are citrus based and clean well and I'd rate them equal. The difference here is Prolix leaves a dry lube and AA is a wet lube. I wish I had these during my military career. Ive cleaned M2, M60, M16, M4, Mk19, M203 so I have a bit of cleaning experience and the break free they issued us sucked. It just made an oily mess.
If you just want to get some copper out then Bore tech eliminator or Cu2 do an awesome job.
For powder fouling, anything will remove it but the really heavy, hard carbon in a bore can only be removed with an abrasive and elbow grease. JB and KG2 are non embedding and will NOT harm the bore. Flitz will NOT harm the bore.
I also cleaned an 03 bore recently that was the worst I ever saw. Nothing visible but carbon with straight copper streaks on it. I started with a 30 cal brush with flitz. This brush got loose so I went to a 338 brush which also got loose after 10 strokes and then went to a 35 cal brush. The 35 cal brush loosened slightly but stayed snug enough to finally find some metal. I ended up having to use KG2 which cleaned it enough to see a bore so pitted that no rifling existed at all. My friend is waiting on a new barrel to arrive. Worst barrel ever but it was cleaned except for the bottom of the pits.