There's Remington fans and there's Savage fans. There's people that own both and there's people that will never buy the other. It's all personal preference.
Shoulder them, shoot them if you can, then make a decision based on your preference. You can read as much as you want online, fact of the matter is that both are fantastic rifles, and both will out-shoot you from the factory. Make a decision based on what you like and what you're comfortable with.
Don't feed him full of false info... I've never seen a gunsmith charge per hour to true a rifle, bed an action, install a barrel, rechamber one, or do a trigger swap/job. They all have set prices for these services. And if your local one charges per hour for these services, that's rediculous. Per hour for repair is one thing, but charging per hour for those other things is rediculous.
And I'm pretty **** sure that regardless of brand, you can replace the stock and install a scope without needing a qualified gunsmith...
I guess all of my untouched factory 700's that are NOT my customs, will shoot sub-1/2" groups (3 or 5 shots) with handloads...But I guess that's not superior to shooting a 1" lolipop at 100 meters...
Part of my work core competency is activity based costing, whether you're willing to accept it or not, those set prices are based on hourly labor rate --- for calculating labor burden rate and profits or composite rates.
It might be presented as a fixed charge for the service rendered but hourly labor rate (+ other associated costs) is actually factored in.
If that's the case, then buy a Browning A-Bolt II... They are the opposite of both... They are smooth and very tight tolerances.Remington actions feel grainy. Savage actions feel sloppy. They both do the job just the same.