Marky_mark
Well-Known Member
VelocityI saw a guy hit a mature Aoudad 4 times with the 143 Eldx from a Creedmoor before it succumbed to the wounds. Two hits back to back at 200 yards and it left the scene. We moved around the mountain and saw it again standing with head hung low. He drilled it again and it stumbled off. He bolted and hit it again and it tumbled.
The next day, same rifle and ammo but different shooter and I (with 6.5-284 and 140 Ballistic Tip) glassed a group on a rocky bluff. We worked around the trees and found a shooting position 360 yards away. We both set up and counted down for simultaneous shots. Mine dropped at the shot and the Creed shot buckled him and he stammered off. We bolted quickly and before he could settle in the scope I put one in the crease between neck and shoulder and it tumbled down dead.
Moral of the story is…At that distance and velocity the ballistic tip did a beautiful job on a fairly tough animal.
The advantage of the magnums is less drop and less wind. If the animals move and you don't have a chance to re range. It will make a difference. Lots of advantages for the magnums. The other thing is you only need one shot. You're not shooting a 5 shot group. You're setting up and focusing on one single shot. Since those cartridges have been developed, they have been made in sheep rifles. Are they the best choice? I don't think so. Are they the worst, if you're not comfortable shooting them, 100% they can be. I've taken a 338 rum on a backpack alpine hunt before. Why? Because everything I shot with it died instantly… that was with 250 gr accubonds too. If you're not comfortable shooting your rifle, no matter what it is, you're in trouble.No one shoots a 28 nosler as well as a 7-08. No one. If they say they do they're kidding themselves. There's tons of data on this. The average persons accuracy degrades around 243win and really goes downhill when you get into the 300wm range. This is true of people that shoot 10s of thousands of rounds a year. And is crazy true of the people that dont.
Again this is well studied.
You don't need those magnums unless you only shoot mpbr, which is fine but it's a lot of recoil when you can get it done with a whole lot less. 280ai has long been considered the sheep hunters choice. The difference between 7-08 and 280ai isn't much until about 500y or so. Which is past most people's cold bore shot capability. But again everyone's accuracy increases by reducing recoil.
Doesn't mean people can't hit things with monster cartridges. It's just less likely you will.
Also sheep aren't bullet proof.