6.5 Creedmoor vs .270 Win vs .257 Weatherby

Being a fellow Californian I feel your pain. I've been loading the ETips in our .308 and 7mm Rem Mags for years now. Like you said you need to push them hard. On paper they will preform at distance but real world testing the expansion you get at lower speeds is nothing to get excited about. They're rated down to 1800 fps but even at 2000 fps the nose barely peels back. I've taken California deer out to 300 yards with the .308 and think that is a good limit for it with the 150 grain ETip.

I converted my .270 Win to a 7mm Rem Mag. Partially to match my brothers so we would always have backup ammo for eachother but also because of the greater range of bullets offered in 7mm. The 150 Etip has a .498 BC and I can launch it several hundred fps faster than the .308. In the .308 I'm getting right around 2,650 fps. I've tried lots of powders but that's about the wall before I get pressure spikes. The 7mag launches the 150 at 2975. I've got them going faster but was not as accurate. The 7mm load carries significantly more velocity at much greater range. I've not taken a deer with the 7mm yet but would not hesitate out to 600 yards with the milk jug tests I've done.

I'd say get the Weatherby so you can push them as hard as possible. Our 7mm Rem Mags the recoil is very tolerable with the 150s. Nothing like shooting 180s!!! I'D consider the 7mm Rem Mag if I were you. The 7mm Etips seem to be easy to find too.
 
davkrat said:
Being a fellow Californian I feel your pain. I've been loading the ETips in our .308 and 7mm Rem Mags for years now. Like you said you need to push them hard. On paper they will preform at distance but real world testing the expansion you get at lower speeds is nothing to get excited about. They're rated down to 1800 fps but even at 2000 fps the nose barely peels back. I've taken California deer out to 300 yards with the .308 and think that is a good limit for it with the 150 grain ETip.

I converted my .270 Win to a 7mm Rem Mag. Partially to match my brothers so we would always have backup ammo for eachother but also because of the greater range of bullets offered in 7mm. The 150 Etip has a .498 BC and I can launch it several hundred fps faster than the .308. In the .308 I'm getting right around 2,650 fps. I've tried lots of powders but that's about the wall before I get pressure spikes. The 7mag launches the 150 at 2975. I've got them going faster but was not as accurate. The 7mm load carries significantly more velocity at much greater range. I've not taken a deer with the 7mm yet but would not hesitate out to 600 yards with the milk jug tests I've done.

I'd say get the Weatherby so you can push them as hard as possible. Our 7mm Rem Mags the recoil is very tolerable with the 150s. Nothing like shooting 180s!!! I'D consider the 7mm Rem Mag if I were you. The 7mm Etips seem to be easy to find too.
Click to expand...
If you recommend the 7mm Rem Mag then why not the 264 WM with a lot more bullet choices ( 85gr HP to 160gr VLD) and less recoil than the 7mm.
 
I personally chose the 7mm over my 270 for the bullet choices. I have ZERO experience with 6.5mm of any kind. Looks like the BC of the 120gr 6.5mm and the 150gr 7mm are basically identical. I'm sure the 6.5 would flatten any buck that's ever lived in California. If you want to go for bear, hogs or an elk once every ten years the 7mag might have a little more oomph.

Regardless of caliber of shooting lead free I say push them as hard as you possibly can. Of the stated options if choose the 264 WM.
 
I have two out of three calibers listed and my choice would be the 6.5 Creedmoor in either a custom or Savage Predator 10.

The 6.5 for whatever reason is inherently accurate and delivers a 140 grain pill with plenty enough energy to take down the game you mentioned. Also, has very little recoil and ammo/reloading components are easy to find.
 
I re-read the OP.

Expanding on what I said before....

The 257Wby is generally a very accurate chambering (sorry Mud). I do lots of loading and testing of lead free bullets. Looking at the 500 yard plus parameter. If It Were Me (IIWM) and I plan on using this load:

257Wby
Barnes TTSX 100
~3500fps (it can go faster)

This will certainly do the job, has the advantage of being "flat" (+- 6") to 400+ yards.

CEBs are also on the list to try. A little better BC.

I have nothing but trouble with the E-Tips. I use lots of other Nosler products but not that one, YYMV.
 
Nothing to be sorry about Fred...It's not like you built my crappy overpriced rifle (former rifle now...). Best thing I ever did with that gun was trade it off. That was a Weatherby issue, but their pride stood in the way of gaining them a repeat customer. Especially since I did absolutely nothing wrong, and the gun came to me, brand new, with a defect.

Nothing at all wrong with the .257 Wby caliber, although I still maintain that case capacity is a bit overzealous for the bullet diameter and currently available weights... But that is neither here, nor there, when it comes to accuracy.

I would like to have another .257 Wby someday, just to re-utilize all the ladder testing loads, factory ammo, brass, and reloading equipment I still have sitting around...

But it's just almost impossible to beat the smoothness and light recoil of the .25-06 AI. Not to mention the speeds that are within 100 fps of the .257 Wby with a lot less powder.
 
The LEAD FREE criteria seems to be missed over and over again. Be glad you don't live in a state where you can just ignore the leadedness of your ammo.
 
davkrat said:
The LEAD FREE criteria seems to be missed over and over again. Be glad you don't live in a state where you can just ignore the leadedness of your ammo.
Click to expand...

A change of scenery is not always a bad thing...Especially when it comes to leaving that crap-hole of a state you currently reside in.

Living in a "free state" is nice.
 
jfseaman said:
I re-read the OP.

Expanding on what I said before....

The 257Wby is generally a very accurate chambering (sorry Mud). I do lots of loading and testing of lead free bullets. Looking at the 500 yard plus parameter. If It Were Me (IIWM) and I plan on using this load:

257Wby
Barnes TTSX 100
~3500fps (it can go faster)

This will certainly do the job, has the advantage of being "flat" (+- 6") to 400+ yards.

CEBs are also on the list to try. A little better BC.

I have nothing but trouble with the E-Tips. I use lots of other Nosler products but not that one, YYMV.
Click to expand...
with the 264WM I am pushing the 100gr Nosler Ballistic tip at 3709 and can go faster. That's with H4831.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 10 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.

Similar threads

B
257 Weatherby vs. 257 STW
Replies
13
Views
23K
meatyrem
meatyrem
T
270 Weatherby vs Winchester
2
Replies
21
Views
4K
MudRunner2005
MudRunner2005
N
308 Win vs 6.5 Creedmoor
5 6 7
Replies
84
Views
11K
gvjm
gvjm
B
6.5-284 vs 270 win
2
Replies
18
Views
41K
barthmonster
B
E
300wsm vs 270 weatherby
Replies
3
Views
10K
winmag
W

Recent Posts

Top