Well I don't know about a beating, I might offer up a slap on the back though, A gun like that makes sense, I've never been one to shy away from a long or tricky shot, my longest shots have exceeded 700 yards, however after more than fifty years of chasing big game in most of the western states I've taken nearly 400 game animals, of these animals more than half came under 50 yards than over, I feel that a short light weight rifle thats well balanced and shoulders well will fill more tags than a long heavy one, my choice of optics were without target turrets or mill dots, my rifle wore either 2x7 or 2.5x8, my caliber of choice the 338 Winchester, my first 338 came in 1975 A ruger M77, being a follower of elmer keith i loaded 76 grs of H4831 behind a 250 gr bullet, i got my first chrongraph in the late 70's the kind you had to shoot through circuit screens, those slugs clocked over 2840 fps, i latter verified this during this age of didgital chronographs, I eventually cut the barrel down to 23in turned the barrel to .570 at the muzzle and a fitted nice peace of bastogne walnut, hunting weight is 8lbs even, A full 1 1/2 lighter than it's original form, about 20 years ago I went even lighter, the finished product wears a 21 in tube a six Interprize stock a 2.5x8 Leopold this one has the B&C reticle hunting weight 6.2 oz, i have never shot anything but Barnes in this rifle, I started with 225 gr slugs and hunted several seasons with them when I tried the Barnes 185gr XLC and the latter triple shock, these185gr slugs clock at just over 3200fps with H414, I latter tried the 160gr but with 414 I couldn't break 3300fps, perhaps a faster powder would change that, however I did hunt with the 160gr for a couple of seasons harvesting a couple of blacktail as well as a couple of Idaho whitetail, I switched back to the heavier slugs but before I did I ran into a beast of a black bear one morning, it measured over 8 feet the shot was about 30 yds, I hit him between the point of the shoulder and base of the neck the bullet exited thru the off ham, the animal dropped where it stood and rolled down the hill, I'm sure if I could have recovered that slug it still would have weighed 160grs, not sure I need a heavier slug but should I encounter another bear the next one might be heading south instead of north so I feel better with the heavier slugs, although the 160's did all a bullet can do, the 338 bore does not suffer from a shortter barrel as badly as the 30 caliber and under do, so I say go for it and have fun,