Reading this thread reminds me of a guy asking me why I'd take one of my bass fishing rods with 17 pound test to the ocean on a recent blue fishing trip. He pointed out the endless setups that would be just that little bit better, and all the reasons why. After listening for a while I politely interrupted and said, "Look, I have it - I'm used to it - I like using it, and it does the job quite well." Then I proceeded to outcatch his big, bad rod setup at nearly 2 to 1 on the water that day.
The point being that the indian is virtually always more important than the arrow. If you're a good indian then hunt deer with whatever you know well and whatever kills them and whatever you enjoy carrying. If you're a bad indian then don't go deer hunting, because bigger, badder guns aren't a crutch for lack of ability.
The .22-250 is a fine deer cartridge. I'll even go further and say that's it's an above average deer cartridge with any good, tough bullet that hits where you aim it in the hands of anyone with any reasonable idea on the cartridge's limitations and where to place the bullet.
Happy hunting.
Very well said.
I remember when I was 5 I could take on all the bad guys in the world with my trusty BB gun. Part was the imagination of a 5 year old, and part was because I never knew I couldnt. Growing up on the ranch I was always sneakin up on something. Grandma's Chickens, Canada Geese, Starlings etc. all fell to my BBgun. Ask a goose hunter if its possible to kill a goose with a BBgun and youll likely get a simmilar response as some to this thread. 12ga 3'' min with alot of recomendations for 3 1/2's......hmmm compare that to a BBgun for energy........... Ya...... Indian, not the arrow. I like that quote.
22-250 a Good idea? probably not. Will it work in the right hands? YEP. Would I recomend it? probably not. Would I try it if I thought I could pull it off and was aware of its limmitations? Heck ya I would.
Go for it, and lemme know what you come up with. Id like to give er a whirl with my 223wssmgun)
if a fish breaks your line it will probably survive. there is no comparison.I shot my biggest buck yet last year with my 223 and a 50gr varmint grenade. i wasn't planning on doing this but we were going out for yotes and a buck decided to chase a doe right in front of us. safe to say i was a little excited. I got lucky and drop him dead. however i had made up some 60gr nosler partitions specifically for deer hunting and i didn't have them with. well i got lucky but shot placement is critical for small calibers. We found the base of the bullet in and around the spine. I shot a bit high but i was lucky. he was easy over 220 lbs.
i would say that if you are a good enough shot and have patience for the right opportunity the 22-250 could be lots of fun. I look at it like catching a master angler on 6lb test. Lots of fun
most of the time i use my 7mm rem mag
a 2in group with a 60 gr n.p. which will penetrate woulb be better than a 50 gr that would not. why dont we hve 'fun' getting a deer we want dead quickley rather than risk a lingering death. is it more important to have fun or be ethical. do tou know the recommended energy for deer and what the energy for 50 gr bullets is at over 200 yards.vssf i have never shot a group over an inch with it. with any load or bullet. i don't even use lapua brass or match primers. win brass and win primers. considering using it on coues in oct. the are dinky