Don't buy either. Save up a little more and you can get a much better scope optically and functionally. Even and additional $100-$200 will get you a large upgrade. Look at the Trijicon at EuroOptic. Here's the 2.5-10 Credo which is all made in Japan with ED glass. A fantastic option.
Trijicon Credo 2.5-10x56 SFP w/ Red MRAD Ranging, 30mm, Matte Black Riflescope 2900025
FREE SHIPPING on Trijicon Credo 2.5-10x56 SFP w/ Red MRAD Ranging, 30mm, Matte Black Riflescope 2900025
www.eurooptic.com