I would agree with that in terms of the craftsmanship and leather but the soles on damners are plain soft and break down too quick. Just my opinion but that soft spongy bottom just doesn't do it fur me. Crispis have an excellent sole and midsole. Crispi, Lowa, meindl and schnees all use the polyurethane midsole which is longer lasting than EVA midsole or the spong that danners use. They also last under heavier weight and rebound during each step better.
A Vibram Montagna soft and spongy? You did say "midsole". My Super Rainforests have not been soft or spongy. I have no idea what they use for a midsole, but on the Super Rainforest the outsole is a Vibram Montagna. Most of the outsoles made by Danner specifically say that they are for grip and are not as long lasting as other soles, and a lot of their boots come with Vibram outsoles which are extremely durable.
I don't have any experience with Crispi, Lowa or Schnees. My wife has some a Meindl boots that are quite good, but she doesn't hike all that much.
I'd be the first to say that my Super Rainforests do not have a super stiff midsole as they were of about medium flex from the beginning, but after putting about 1250 miles on my first pair(I work in them) my second pair was equally flexible within about two weeks, so it was sort of a light break-in and then a pretty steady end result. I'm also a major fan my Red Wing Super Loggers, except they're heavy, and I don't like the tall logger heel. After wearing out the outsole, I resoled with a Montagna instead of a Logger, and like them better, but they are still heavy. They are a much stiffer boot than the Danner Super Rainforest, and come with a heavier insulated option, but I like the Super Rainforest better, so I just wear thicker socks. I don't know if Danner makes a good climbing boot, but as a hunting or approach boot, I think they are pretty darn good, and last a long time.
Because I put so many miles on boots, I'm only interested in a stitch down boot that is readily resole-able. Anything that is molded on and/or has a rand is out for me. Not for performance purposes but for longevity purposes. The same goes for nylon panels or tongues. For me it's 100% leather and a stitch down construction or I'm out. If Redwing still made the Super Logger in the US, and offered a non-metallic toe, I'd probably buy another pair and resole with a Montagna right out the gate.
I'm about to send my first pair of Super Rainforests in for a recrafting(around 2000 miles on them) and when I get them back, I'll send in my second pair which has about 1000 miles on them.
I have about 2500 miles on my RedWing Super Loggers and they are barely into the resole. The leather and hardware my have a slight edge on Danner, but they are very heavy, and the metallic toe is cold in spite of their superior insulation. Craftsmanship was probably no better than equal to Danner. I think that Danner and RedWing both makes some really great boots at their top end.
I've only been wearing my boots every day for about five years. Prior to that i only hunted in my boots, and good boots lasted essentially forever.