Tough question-We've gone through a spell where we bought all the kids Ruger 77's to start, and nary a clinker so far. I had a little #3 .375 Win that I shot cast bullets with. I consider the 1" 100yd 10 shot group with it to be one of my high points. Great little trainer as well. The little semi-auto 44 and levers have all shot well in their ranges. For some reason Ruger isn't on the list.
I picked Winchester, but there's a decade or 2 in the middle that are an embarrassment. If I was buying off the shelf today to hunt this season it would be the Winchester I think they're calling it Extreme Weather, 338, or 300 win