The responses are both what I would expect from each company. the Vortex service and warranty is their cornerstone. NF did miss a great opportunity to both display a little humanity and reward a loyal customer. The least they could have done is looked at the scopes, they were in a safe. Maybe destroyed, maybe not completely. That would have also verified that yes, this is a great customer that has spent alot of money with us. He also probably associates with other high end shooters. With all the samples, promos, etc. they could easily comp a scope or two from a program or refurb. That would help a great customer get a fraction back. It would also make pub like this a selling point versus a black mark, even though they did nothing wrong. I suppose they don't want to set a precedent, but they did miss a chance to do something good for a great customer and probably the bottom line without a big outlay.