My first "genuine long range" rifle was what my brother recommended - a Savage Model 10 FCP in 308 for $650. I could not be more pleased with it's performance! There's just as much chance of me hitting the 980-yard gong at the monthly match I attend as the three dozen or so other shooters (some of whom are SWAT snipers or PRS shooters) with rifles that cost thousands more. Not that I can shoot as good as them but I have been shooting since I was a little kid.
I could upgrade it with a GRS Berserk stock for about $450 but the thing already enables me to keep my scores up with my brother who shoots a $6,500 6.5 Creedmoor rig! Savage is now also offering the Model 10 FCP straight from the factory with the GRS Berserk stock. If I wasn't looking to get another toy then I would just buy the GRS Berserk for it and call it good. But...
Like you I did a lot of research, but I also wanted something different than just another Remington 700. I didn't want a heavy target rifle with a weird stock that was only good for shooting steel or paper from a bench. I wanted to be able to carry it fairly easily, so in a pinch I could even hunt with it. I also wanted a 3-lug bolt, which really narrowed my choices down to Weatherby, Browning, Thompson Center or Sako.
I almost went with Thompson Center's LRR (Long Range Rifle, from Smith & Wesson's Performance Center) but it's relatively heavy weight concerned me. At the match I usually attend I have to carry it up and down ridges, and I'm over 50-years-old. So I chose the Browning X-Bolt Max Long Range in 6.5 Creed. I can't wait to pick it up this weekend (stupid California waiting period.)
The only thing I'm a little concerned about is what Browning calls a "heavy sporter" weight barrel. No wonder the T/C LRR is heavier! I'm not so sure this "heavy sporter" barrel will work as well as a heavier barrel. If it stays true for 6-shot strings then I guess I should be happy but I'll only be merely satisfied. If it stays true for 8-shot strings I'll be delighted. However, I'm not holding my breath.
I'm trying to justify my choice by telling myself it's a hybrid rifle, good for long range targets yet still usable for a hunting rifle. We shall see after I can get the dough together to buy a decent scope for it. Keeping fingers crossed.