is it not also true that it's easier to work up loads with super low velocity deviations than with lighter pills, even if the bc isn't that different? And is it not also often observed with magnum cases and, well, whatever you'd even call these behemoths, that the heaviest bullets realize the energy potential of the cartridge much more readily, they're more efficient? Even in the dimunutive 300 win mag I've come to see no point in shooting anything under 180 grains as you can't even drive them that much faster, they certainly don't shoot appreciably flatter. I have also found the tightest extreme spread numbers with old school 220 round nose bullets.[/QUOTE]
In all of my testing with my wildcats starting in 2003, in every instance, using the heaviest bullets possible produced the tightest velocity spreads. Not only that, groups measured at 500, 800 and 1000 yards ALWAYS were smallest with the heavies, even when velocity spreads were not dramatically different.
As far as kenetic energy, since kenetic energy is calculated by the square of the velocity, lighter, extremely fast bullets can show some impressive kenetic energy levels, however, while this looks good on paper, in real life kenetic enegy payload can be a bit misleading if one does not have a good understanding on how it works in real life.
Kenetic energy can be useful in comparing different cartridges shooting similar weight projos but in the same cartridge, comparing different bullet weights, its less effective at making a comparision, again, because velocity in the formula is squared so more importance is given to velocity then bullet weight.
Back to using heavy bullets and the benefits of such. In my professional opinion, the heavy bullet weights, especially in very large capacity designs, provides the resistance needed for proper and consistent powder ignition. Also promotes a more effective and complete powder burn. Resistence increases pressure, pressure improves the ignition and burn characteristics of smokeless gunpowder, especially the ultra slow burning powder we use alot of.