For low recoil and deer my vote is the 6.5x47. I know you said maybe the odd elk. But sounds like you could take a different gun for elk. The 130 Berger hunting and 130 gr Accubond both perform awesome on deer. My 130 Berger load holds 1820 fps out to 750 yards. For a low recoil, good barrel life you can't go wrong with the 6.5x47. Its a impressive little case in my opinion.