One thing I have noticed is everyone has their on thoughts and opinion about everything. Yes the 7mm Dakota Imp will probably not do anything that the 7mm RUM will, but that is yet to be seen because right now it has not been tested. However what ever it does it will do it with a lot less powder.
I have more than 35 years of experience in reloading and have had and shot many different calibers from 22PPC to 30-338 Lapua Imp. I have also built more than 20 custom rifles and accurized 100's for myself and others. I shot for several years in Bench Rest competition. So basically what I am saying is I have considerable experience in various calibers and their performance. When I decide on a new caliber there is a reason and that reason comes from many hours of research. My research produced the design for the 7mm Dakota Improved.
With the Dakota 2.50 case length you can design your throat for even the 200 GR Wildcat bullet and still have room in your mag box. Because of this you can also use detachable magazines. Also look at what is setting and breaking all the long range records. Needless to say it is not 7mm RUMS. It is shorter larger diameter case designs like 7WSM, 6mmBR, etc. and that is another reason for the 7mm Dakota. Like I said I have shot many calibers and it is my opinion that the case designs like the 7WSM and 7MM Dakota are just more efficient and accurate. All the other cases 7mm-300WTHBY, 7MM STW, 7MM RUM are to long which cause bullet seating issues and also only the 7 RUM will run with this Dakota Improved case.
Brass is very easy to find and the brass I have purchased was very consistent. You basically prep your brass and turn the necks, fill the case with trailboss, stuff a patch in the case throat, fire and your ready to go. This is going to be a Long Range Rifle. The action is a Stiller TAC 300, Krieger LV Fluted 8.5 Twist Barrell, McMillian Game Scout Stock, Jewell Trigger and a SSG Vaporizer Brake. I do all the smithing except for the chamber job. I have my parts at Straight Shot Gunsmithing now and expect to have them back and finish the bedding, stock work, gun-kote and assembly before the end of the month if things go as planned.
I just sold a 30-338 Lapua Imp. that I built that would shoot all day long in the mid 3s. It would push a 210 VLD over 3,400 but my load was at 3,225. At 700 yds the 7mm Dakota Imp. catches up with the 30-338 and at 1100 yds it passes it and I am sure it will be more accurate. The 7mm bullet also has less wind drift and will do all this with 15 grains less of powder in a 26 inch barrel.
Well this is my spill for the 7mm Dakota Improved. Personally I had rather have the standard 7MM Dakota over the 7RUM and the other cases that was mentioned. But that is why all these different calibers exist. Every ones likes and wants are different, just like opinions.