Brakes are a different animal than suppressors, and I treat them as such when making these types of decisions.
I've installed brakes with minimal shoulders, using Rocksett to secure them rather than relying on torque where you'd crush the shoulder with the necessary torque.
This is plain geometry. A brake that's an inch or two long- is much more forgiving than a 10" long suppressor in an application where concentricity is critical. I still think a mount that indexes on the muzzle is the best option from a technical and aesthetic perspective.
JMO, YMMV.