I have to shoot quite a few every year. My parents live along a river and get a bunch of them. One year they went on vacation go see family for a week, they left with 40 some chickens, came back to 5, the rest all got killed by coons. That chicken coup looked like a slaughter house....dead carcasses everywhere, blood splattered on the walls....it was grousome, my father and I referenced it as "grendal and the house of men", it was bad. Once they find a honey pot, they come back every night.
I have a foxpro with "coon fight" sound, I go out right after sunset, and start calling. I learned the hard way, they aren't like coyotes, they are aggressive, they come in hard and way, way fast. I rarely have to wait more than 3 minutes before I see a set of eyes bouncing towards me, and it's usually under a minute....they also don't seem to care if you put light on them, as long as it's not directly in their eyes. I regularly shoot 3-5 in my one stand a night when I go out, one after another after another, and my guns aren't supressed, they just keep coming. I use my ar-15 .223, I have used a 22, and it absolutely kills them, but I have had a few run 50-100 yards after taking a shoulder hit with a stinger. Shots are usually 50 yards+ from my calling location, so the .223 works out better. A 22 hornet would also be great. I just have a preference towards a semi auto and high capacity....because of the following story.
When I say I learned the hard way....first time I went after them was after the occurence I mentioned, grendal and the house of men. I researched and found "coon fight" was popular and seemed to work well, so figured I would give it a go with my foxpro. Had a light mounted to my ar, and went to a spot by the river I knew might be good. Leaned up against a fence post on a steep hill just above the river, set up my call on the post in front of/just down the hill from me. It was steep enough, the call was about level with my head. Started calling like I do for night time coyotes, figured I would wait 3-5 minutes before shining a light. It was very dark, no moon yet and overcast, not even star light. Well about a minute or two after starting the caller, I heard something that sounded like the snarls and growls from my caller, but it didn't quite match.....then I heard the fence squeaking, and saw him. A big coon was biting my e-caller!! I stood up, and I saw the dark shadow jump down and start charging me.....I didn't have time to turn on my light, and immediate action was needed, I pointed at the approaching shadow and started sending rounds heads up, adjusting my aim with each shot as the muzzle flash illuminated the angry charging coon, my final (and 8th shot) shot was within about two feet of me when I just figured I was going to get chewed on and started kicking at it, I felt one solid hit into something soft with my boot and then backpedaled and turned to run up the hill a few steps. Once I realized he wasn't on me, I turned around and turned on my flashlight and started scanning.....saw the coon about 10 yards down hill trying to run away, but apparently one of my 8 rounds fired in about a second and a half made contact, his guts were tangled up in a sage bush. I put a final round through him to finish him off, and took a second to recap what just happened, and calm myself down. I decided I would call it a night after that ha ha!!
So now when I call, I have a light on as soon as I start the caller, and begin scanning. I catch their eyes, and just keep the main beam of the light above them, direct light seems to slow em down or they don't come in. But with just edge light, they come as close as I let them get, about 25-50 yards or so depending on if they cross the river or if it is frozen and they walk across, and I dump em. But that is why the only gun I have in my hand is an ar when coon hunting, other people have brought bolt 22's and other caliber bolt guns when going with me, but not me. If I would have had a bolt gun that night, I almost certainly would have got chewed up a bit!!
Below is the coon from the story. Photo is blurry, I was probably still shaking with adrenaline ha ha
View attachment 179344