Good thread. Sifting through all the crap in the low to mid price range may be the best thing this thread has going for it. There is more crap to sift through than ever so a guy does have to be aware of going cheap to start and end up spending a lot down the road because of necessary upgrades. I don't agree with everything said here mostly because this is a LR site and LR hunting requires precision and precision in many cases, especially over the long run, cannot be maintained with inferior and less expensive materials. But there is a place IMO for a proven mid range scope for a lot of guys that shoot maybe out to 1/2 mile or a touch further.
I think one of the biggest mistakes guys on a budget make is prioritizing glass quality too high on their list. Glass quality is one of the big factors that cause scope prices to soar. With today's scopes IMO it is pretty easy to find glass that is good enough to get the job done even in the low to mid range. It may not be the best viewing experience and you may have to deal with edge clarity issues and loss of clarity as magnification increases and maybe even a more critical eye-box but at the end of the day they will work to get the job done.
It is my suggestion that guys look at durability, and turret repeatability (especially if you are going to be dialing your turrets for varying distances) first to find a scope that is in your budget but won't let you down in the field with the trophy of a lifetime is staring at you.
One of my other passions is precision airguns. I have been shooting those since I was a kid and they are really one of the reasons I ended up getting into LR centerfire shooting. Sounds kinda strange but dialing 3 or 4 revs on a scope just to get out to 100-150 yards is really good groundwork for what LR hunting will require. And being able to shoot hundreds of shots per day with no recoil fatigue while only spending a couple bucks on pellets makes for about the best practice a guy can get!
Anyway, because most diehard airgunners own many airguns (sometimes many, many airguns
) guys just can't afford the prime scopes for all their guns. So the low to mid range scopes get a lot of use and therefore the jewels really begin to stand out. For those that aren't aware, spring and piston powered airguns are much harder on scopes than a standard or magnum centerfire round. It is the double recoil and speed of the recoil that is so hard on scopes. Needless to say you find out very quickly what will hold up and what won't.
The Bushnell line has always been the mainstay of airguns scopes. Especially their 3200 and 4200 series. Tough as nails, very repeatable and excellent glass, especially in the 4200 line.
Weaver is also a very good performer for toughness, turret quality and good glass for the price. Their V16 is one of my favorites. I have 3 and they all are on magnum airguns and are going strong after 1000's and 1000's of shots. The have semi target turrets as well which makes for great practice for LRH. The Grand slam is also a good option.
Nikon has always been a big player as well. Not surprised many guys are finding good luck with their Nikons. Some lines are better than others though so I would be careful in just choosing any Nikon.
Hawke is probably the newest optic line to hit the airgun industry but it has pretty much taken it by storm the last few years. Very good prices and warranty and they have a really versatile lineup and their scopes are built to take a beating. Their repeatability is also very good. Glass quality has pretty much been their weakness but 2011 and beyond is more than acceptable. They also have a really functional 1/2 mil hash reticle for those that wish to try out a BDC reticle.
The SWFA SS line should also be at the top of anyone's list who is on a budget. Their scopes are some of the most durable and repeatable scopes out there IMO and this goes for even their older, lower priced fixed scopes. Their newer additions, 10xHD, 3-9x42, and 5-20 are excellent in all regards and are at the top of my list for price to quality/feature ratio. The newer models aren't low priced and some aren't even mid priced but they compete with the elite manufacturers for a fraction of the price so in that regard they are high value low cost for many folks that are looking for a happy medium. This is especially true if one is looking for a good priced FFP scope with matching reticle and turrets. The SWFA line is MIL/MIL and either FFP or fixed power.
I guess depending on a guys budget the scopes I mentioned may or may not be considered low priced. But these would be the ones I would feel confident relying on with a good record of durability and repeatability while still allowing me to save some cash. This is a LR site and the precision workings of a scope's internals should not be underestimated to pull off the kind of shots that LR hunters require. In this game, especially for those shooters that constantly dial their turrets, I do think over time the lower priced scopes will cause a loss of accuracy and repeatability for you. Not saying that as an absolute as I am sure there are a few wonders out there. I guess I am just reminding folks that there ARE some things that are critically important to repeatable performance that can't be scrimped on. Turret repeatability and overall durability are a couple of those IMO. Guys that shoot only to MPBR or those that use BDC style reticles can in some ways get away with less quality in a scope because once they get their scope set they seldom have to change anything so quality of internals, etc isn't quite as important is it would be to other shooters. For what I consider LR shooting, 600 yards and beyond, turret quality and repeatability does become a critical factor guys shouldn't overlook just to save a few bucks.
So it goes for guys on a budget trying to find that happy medium between price, quality and features.
Scot E.