To the OP:
Your buddy is going to have to make his own decision about what he needs or wants to do with the rifle.
Even though it may not apply to this situation, this is what I went through:
When I was going through my dilemma with my 300 WM LR, there were some people telling me to send it back. Let Remington fix their mistake. Don't take it to a gunsmith, you'll void your warranty...
The SINGULAR thought that kept crossing my mind at the time, is "Do I REALLY want the knuckleheads who created this steaming pile, the SAME people who allowed it out their door to be sold to me, to work on it some more?
I mean really?
What?
How does that even scan?
Then there was the logic of preserving a "warranty" from a company that turns out such ****, that everyone seems to know someone who got burned?
I got news for ya. When I get bent over and prison raped by a company like that, the LAST thing I'm worried about is "preserving my warranty", and the FIRST thing I'm worried about is not standing in line for it all over again!!
I USED to have the utmost respect for Remington. The FACT is, it's just not the same company it was.
I never would have believed it either, until I got burned first hand. I bought that rifle with CONFIDENCE and TRUST. Didn't even inspect it that close!
I think that is what hurts the worse.
You can bet that has changed now!
I have COMPLETELY inspected EVERY rifle, and walked away when it hasn't met my scrutiny, but not before telling the sales person what exactly is wrong with it.
In the end, I ended up happy with what I got in a custom rifle out of it, but as you can tell from this post, it still stings a bit.
Since then, I have bought 3 Savage rifles, a 110 FCP HS 338 Lapua, a 110 FCP SR 308 win, and a 110 30-06 Springfield. I really enjoy the DIY aspect of these rifles!
I have also bought 2 Christensen Arms rifles, a BA Tactical 338 Lapua, and a Ridgeline 300 Win Mag.
So... really... it cost them more than it cost me.