Either of those reasons could explain your result. What's the load data? I would at first glance suspect excessive pressure.
Yep, oversizing and thin brass. What dies?
Jeff
You are smart by tossing that brass.
Jeff
You seem like a rational person. So consider a mistake as raising the probability of other mistakes -that you don't know about yet.
I suggest you pick up Amazon.com: Handloading for Competition Making the Target Bigger. (9780962692598): Glen D. Zediker: Books
You probably won't put it down once you start reading it.