Fit and comfort are super important! What works for me likely won't work for your particular feet! The same thing is true with insoles. I've tried Superfeet and they make my feet hurt BAD! My particular feet need padding and none of the Superfeet offer this. I've had a lot better luck with $30 super padded insoles I pick up at Sportsman's Warehouse. It may be worth a long drive to a store to try out boots, insoles, and socks. If not it may be a matter of trial and error? Knowing if your particular feet work best for high arches, padding, narrow vs wide, lots of ankle support, etc is a starting point.