I tried dry firing a snapcap...and YES the bolt IS difficult to open
It's not my rifle, been working up a load for it for the past several weeks
What could it be??
I don't know it it always did that? Could I have done something to it to make the bolt difficult to open, by hand loading for it??
I've never looked at a S&W rifle so I don't know anything about them. My guess is, the cocking mechanism is the issue not the load. It could be something worn or something as simple as needing lubed. Is it a 60° or a 90° bolt?
As for your load, I think you are at the point of too little density with 58 gr of IMR4831. A general rule is to not go below 80% of the case volume. I think H1000 powder will give you the best results with that bullet.