TRexF16
Well-Known Member
Yes, but for a given pressure level, a 9% increase in case volume will not gain 4% in velocity, it will only gain about 2.25% in velocity (25% of the increase in volume). This is just the physics of how cartridges behave.
In Feenix's question above, first, we must recognize a 30-06 will easily do 3000 FPS at 60K PSI, not 2900 FPS.
And if the Gibbs achieved 3285 FPS (which I completely believe it did), it did not do so at 60K PSI. More likely it was closer to .270 Win territory of 65K PSI, which again, I contend was probably perfectly safe. But if the 30-06 basic case had been loaded to the same pressure level with the same powder and bullet (not the same powder charge, it would have been a lower charge to get the same pressure in the smaller case), it would have likely produced somewhere north of 3100 FPS. [EDIT - and I should add, probably just as safely as the Gibbs went north of 3200 FPS - that's kind of my point - the gains noted for "improved" cartridges are mostly achieve by increased pressure, and I write this as an improved fan]
Regards,
Rex
In Feenix's question above, first, we must recognize a 30-06 will easily do 3000 FPS at 60K PSI, not 2900 FPS.
And if the Gibbs achieved 3285 FPS (which I completely believe it did), it did not do so at 60K PSI. More likely it was closer to .270 Win territory of 65K PSI, which again, I contend was probably perfectly safe. But if the 30-06 basic case had been loaded to the same pressure level with the same powder and bullet (not the same powder charge, it would have been a lower charge to get the same pressure in the smaller case), it would have likely produced somewhere north of 3100 FPS. [EDIT - and I should add, probably just as safely as the Gibbs went north of 3200 FPS - that's kind of my point - the gains noted for "improved" cartridges are mostly achieve by increased pressure, and I write this as an improved fan]
Regards,
Rex