Ran the stuff from home Depot for close to an hour, brass looks clean and shiny, I can still see anneal on some brass but going away, as far as I can see crushed walnut shell is crushed walnut shell no matter where you get it from, lizard stuff works good, home Depot works good, same as Lyman or whatever brand you get, I've always been happy with the way it works but not the price, well wasn't too bad till lately. I would also say that the home Depot stuff isn't dusty so far, I like that. I also think I put too much baking soda in my last batch, really dusty when you move it, I threw out the mix, definitely not dealing with all that dust.