• If you are being asked to change your password, and unsure how to do it, follow these instructions. Click here

anyone admit to making a terrible shot

I've had more than one.

First was my first deer hunting experience back in PA. I was using my first deer rifle which was a Rem 243 with iron sights. I was up in a tree stand and a 3x3 buck is coming down the trail and stops about in front of me. It was a front slightly quartering shot about 45* down almost right below me. I decided to take a head shot since he was so close and the rack wasn't anything special. I fired and he turned and ran off much to my surprise and dismay. I got down and found a good bit of frothy blood so I figured the bullet went low and probably went through the jaw and trachea. Not sure why it went low other than my sight height was a little over an inch above the bore. So I proceeded to track it down off the wooded hill to where it went into a country club. I got permission to follow into the club by a security guy who was driving by and tracked it through the golf course which was closed for the season. Came to a stream and the blood trail was getting very sparse. Crossed the stream, no blood. I search up and down, still no blood, so I started back and ran into another guy who was also on the trail. He said let's go back and see if we can find him. There was a stand of trees that he thought the buck might have gone in to and he was right. Kicked it out and gut shot it on the run with his 220 B and it ran into another stand of trees at the other end of the club next to a residential sub-division. I posted on one end and he pushed up through from the other end. Here comes the buck with it's bloody tongue hanging out and stops about 15' from me broadside. I should have drilled him through the shoulder but put one through the ribs at point blank range. The buck bolted and ran out of the woods into the sub-division and some lady started screaming "you hunters....." We unloaded our rifles and walked out onto the street and I felt like crap. We couldn't very well track it anymore through everyone's backyard. 2 days later up in the same stand, a small spike walks under and I drilled it through the lungs and heart. It ran down hill to the toward my truck and piled up.

Next, antelope hunting in Eastern Montana. Back in camp for lunch with a couple of my hunting buddies and here comes a small band of goats by the camp at less than a 100 yds. I had a doe/fawn tag and an either sex (buck tag). No Bucks, so I decide to shoot a doe. Up with the rifle, crosshairs on target and let it go. Down with the rifle and one doe is down and another is moving very slowly while the rest of the band is bolting off. Looking closer, I can see intestine dragging from the offside of the other doe. Realizing what I had just done I put the rifle back up and finish her off. Gut them and drag them back to camp. One of my buddies was nice enough to put his doe tag on one of the does so I could still shoot a buck. Needless to say it was more than a little embarrassing and a big lesson learned about shooting into multiple targets.

Next, cow elk hunting during extended late season about 5 years ago. After walling around most of the day I found a good size herd feeding in sage pasture. I was just inside the edge of the trees and put a stalk on and finally crawled up behind some sage to about 150-200 yds away from the nearest cow. I did not have a rest for the rifle and am usually pretty good offhand or off the knee. The rifle was a newly purchased SAKO Finnlight 300 WSM that was a very disappointing 2 MOA shooter but the only operational rifle I had at the time. Still, inside 200 yds I should easily be able to put one through the kill zone. I put my elbow on one knee and attempt to place the crosshairs on target but having a little difficulty holding steady. I do my best and take the shot and the cow goes down. I walk up and can see it is thrashing around, with back legs paralyzed. I put one through the head to finish her. The first shot struck the lower part of the spine just behind the last rib, about 2' from POA. Next time, take a little more time to settle down for a good steady shot.
 
I get buck fever and I shake all over the place. When I was 18 and came back from college for a Thanksgiving hunt, I was placed in a tree stand overlooking my buddies corn field. I had a Marlin 336, in .35 Remington with a nice redfield scope on it. The furthest shot in any direction of this field was 100 yards. A nice 8 pointer walked out literally within 5 minutes of me getting into the stand. I fired on a perfect 75 yard broadside shot and saw him jump about 5 feet into the air then sprint into the woods. I thought I made an awesome heart lung shot. I got down from the stand and saw pieces of bones and fur with very little blood. I knew instantly that I hit low and took out his front left leg. I felt nauseated. My dad and two buddies tracked him till about 3 am (made the shot around 530 pm) when the woods exploded with coyotes, howling and running around us. I figured they found the deer before us and mother nature got the last laugh. Since then I practiced and practiced and I used small game hunting as a prep. To say the least I dont miss anymore.
 
I was bow hunting once on a frosty morning. Place looked good, and I set up inside several tree that sort of grew into a cluster. Somewhere a long the way I fell asleep! While asleep an eight point buck was grazing about twenty feet from me. There were some guys bird hunting, and they fired several shots in the air trying to get my attention, but I was out like a rock!

Another time I was coyote hunting inside a drainage ditch. I saw three nice dogs out around 450 yards, and didn't want to shoot as there were cattle nearby. ($$$) Anyway they came into about 300 yards and it was starting to get dark. I pulled out my mouse squeaker for that last urge. A big dog actually came up from behind me, and literally jumped over me. I shot him with a 22-250 as he was heading out at top speed. He rolled over, and got right back up! We got up to find him, and saw lots of blood, but no dog! Went back the next morning, and saw even more blood. but never saw that dog! He'd have gone close to forty pounds, and I hit him right behind his front legs quartering away. Told the farmer, and he said he'd keep an eye out for him. But he never found him as well. That's when I switched over to a 6mm.
gary
 
I'll admit it. I made a bad shot this year. The overall situation turned south quickly and I had a split decision to make and a shot was taken. I ended up hitting my antelope right through the hams broadside. Fortunately, he wasn't able to run and a follow up dropped him without even so much as a kick afterwords. The whole thing was over in less than 10 seconds which while it wasn't clean but was still fairly quick. Quick and clean is always the goal but it is impossible for every hunter to be 100% clean all the time. My shot was only a bit over 440 yards which by all rights should be a chip shot for me. There are no guarantees in hunting, only putting as many odds in your favor as possible.

M
 
...Shot the deer and it dropped on the spot. It was early so i kept hunting but didnt see anything else. At dark i went over to guy it and found it laying there dead with a broken back...
...I just as easily could have sent that deer off to die a terrible death.
It sounds to me as if it did "die a terrible death."
I think leaving it there was the "terrible" part, not the shot.
 
Most hunters who have hunted for many years have made poor shots at some time or other. I have too and lost animals as a result...but learned from the experience.

One of the most remarkable "screw ups" I remember was when I was in my late twenties. Deer season was opening the next day and for some reason I had not been able to get to the range to check my zero. Not to worry, I had a place behind my house where a 100 yd shot could be made so I took a target to the base of a poplar tree and of course I didn't have any thumbtacks or anything to fasten the target to the tree. Light bulb! I drag out my trusty old tinker swiss army knife and use it to hold the target...you know where this is going....First shot dead center on the knife at the top of the target! Could not have hit the knife if I had been trying!

Oh well, knife wasn't very sharp anyway.
 
who said it was left there. We harvest every bit of the meat out of those deer and work harder then about any hunters i know to recover every deer we shoot at.
It sounds to me as if it did "die a terrible death."
I think leaving it there was the "terrible" part, not the shot.
 
I've been there too. In fact I made two bad shots in the same day a few hours apart. These were both while bow hunting. The first a really nice 8 pointer came down the trail I was watching from my tree stand. He stopped at exactly 23 yds, well maybe not (exactly) this was in the days before good laser range finders, in fact I think it was before bad laser range finders so that will tell you how long ago. Back then you would pace off your distance to your stand and note the locations by survey tape or a landmark. I'm sure some of you have been there. Any way the buck comes in and stops broadside with his nose on the ground facing to the left, I drew took careful aim good anchor point and all that, when I released I hit him in the ***, WTH he turns and runs out of there. Hoping I may of hit femoral artery I get down to look for blood. There was blood but it was dark red mussel blood. I waited a few min. then took up the trail which was pretty easy to follow since there was a very light dusting of snow on the ground. I followed it for about 200 yds. until it gave out completely, showing no signs of being hit fatally I went back to my stand. About 10 minutes after settling in here comes a 9 point stops in the exact same place only facing right so I come to full draw release and hit him squarely in the neck. Holy crap I can't believe this, so I get down find about two drops of blood nothing else. By now I'm really confused and am thinking my sights have to have been knocked out of alignment some how.
I stopped by my buddies house to relay the story and to check my sights there dead on. This took place on a Tuesday, fast forward to Saturday opening day of gun season,(shotgun&muzzle loader) Indiana. I'm up in the same stand at first light still being confused on what took place a few days before I'm looking towards the spot both deer were standing with my binoculars and notice about 20' out from my stand a small limb,(were talking about the diameter of a tooth pick) with a fresh nick in it. The only thing I can figure is one of the shoots hit this limb with the broad head and the other maybe the fletching barely touched it, sending both shots slightly right.
Now here is where it gets crazy. I hear a deer running through the leaves about 80 yds away look through the bino's and see a doe right behind her is a nice buck. When they both stop I already have him in the cross hairs. I make the shot a perfect double lung he goes maybe 20 yds. and is down for the count. I get down go over and start field dressing him. By now my buddy is there we drag him out load him in the truck and take him home. As I'm getting ready to hang him and get him skinned I noticed a wound on his neck that is completely healed over I stuck the point of my knife in the wound and hit metal, when I dug it out there is my broad head intact. It was the second buck I shot a few days before. He showed no indication off being injured. I only hope the first one fared as well. Hunt long enough it's gonna happen. I still have the broad head along with a picture of that buck hanging in my office.
 
who said it was left there. We harvest every bit of the meat out of those deer and work harder then about any hunters i know to recover every deer we shoot at.
You did; that is why I "quoted" you!
You know full well what I'm talking about; but I'll spell it out for you again!

I'm talking about you "leaving it there" for hours, "dying a terrible death!"
That is the "TERRIBLE" part!
Anyone can make a bad shot, and it is nothing to be ashamed of, (unless you are shooting beyond your ability.) The "terrible" part is your arrogance in thinking you couldn't make a bad shot; then being opposite of "work harder" by being too lazy to go check on your animal.
 
You did; that is why I "quoted" you!
You know full well what I'm talking about; but I'll spell it out for you again!

I'm talking about you "leaving it there" for hours, "dying a terrible death!"
That is the "TERRIBLE" part!
Anyone can make a bad shot, and it is nothing to be ashamed of, (unless you are shooting beyond your ability.) The "terrible" part is your arrogance in thinking you couldn't make a bad shot; then being opposite of "work harder" by being too lazy to go check on your animal.

Being a bit harsh? After all he did own up to it and started this thread. I don't know if arrogance plays in it or not but the lesson learned is go check the shot.
 
You did; that is why I "quoted" you!
You know full well what I'm talking about; but I'll spell it out for you again!

I'm talking about you "leaving it there" for hours, "dying a terrible death!"
That is the "TERRIBLE" part!
Anyone can make a bad shot, and it is nothing to be ashamed of, (unless you are shooting beyond your ability.) The "terrible" part is your arrogance in thinking you couldn't make a bad shot; then being opposite of "work harder" by being too lazy to go check on your animal.


How's that soapbox treating you?



t
 
My worst shot ever was a close shot at 50yrds on a deer.
The only rifle I had with me at the time was my 375, I had just put a new set of rings/bases and a new scope on her and had just finished bore sighting. I made sure I wound the reticle up to be about 2" higher than boreline, as usual when boresighting. I hadn't had a chance to actually check POI when a doe walked out feeding just behind one of my sheds. I held high on the shoulder and proceeded to shoot her right in the knee joint. What a shock that was!
I was able to shoot her again and put her down, but it was close to being a very bad outcome because it was only luck that a fence pulled her up long enough for me to hold over her back and fire again. It's the only fence on my property that has mesh on it, it's my potty calf paddock.
I learnt right there to NEVER use a rifle unless you KNOW where it's hitting.

I have felt really stupid ever since that incident, and don't plan on repeating it any time soon.

Cheers.
gun)
 
I've had a few...

A few years ago I had a cull buck that I bow-shot and pinned his hips. I recovered him but it was not a good shot and not a good feeling as I knew it took a long time for him to expire. I never figured out why it was such a bad miss - I guess I just didn't give the shot the respect it deserved, and just wasn't fully focused. It felt crappy and I try to avoid it ever happening again.

A stupid one I had when I first started hunting: I live in the shotgun zone and when I hunt here it is almost entirely with my bow. One year we get a really nice, no wind, light snow day a week into gun season. My wife is gone, so I decide to go sit in a tree. I have some slugs laying around and an old mossberg 500 with a bead sight. I figure if I keep my shots to bow range I've got no issues. About 10 minutes in I have a decent buck chasing a doe pop out in front of me and dead stop broadside at 25 yards. I line him up and slowly squeeze - BANG - drops like a rock DRT. First gun kill ever, man this is really easy they just drop. I walk up and see no hole??? It took me a bit to find the slug-sized through-and-through, dead center neck shot about 6 inches below his head. Not so good... But a good common sense lesson: if you haven't shot with it, you don't know where it shoots - *******.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 12 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top