Taking it to a local 'smith tomorrow to get it looked over, headspace checked, etc just so I can (hopefully) rule that out...
Well the headspace is perfect, rifle is completely good to go. Must have just been toast brass and maybe I'm bumping the shoulder too far...
After shooting the test loads with Retumbo and not having near the accuracy as H1000, I may just buy an 8 lb can of H1000, start low, and find the happy spot. My rifle just seems to like that combo for accuracy...